Conversation science, finding a middle ground on AI, the match of M.C. Escher, and more
It’s been a busy October and early November — with the usual, inexorable change around us. In this issue’s features find four (4! — it’s been a minute since the last issue) posts that show just how much our AI moment is pushing learning in two directions at the same time: both into and away from the technology. Two posts focus on analog actions — humanities classes and long form reading — and two others focus on seismic shifts in today’s world: the prospect of giving up on homework and writing in an entirely new way. Much food for thought here.
On these themes, find posts this week on conversation science, fitness mindsets, prescribing art to feed your brain, the math behind M.C. Escher’s art, and much more.
These and more, enjoy!
Peter
PS. I’m happy to share a list of engagements coming up in the months ahead, and would love to connect if you’ll be at any:
November 18: “Ethics and AI” — Academy for Teachers, online, based in NYC
The final session in a five-part online course. It’s a virtual PD offering, available to register for a small fee. We’ll be focusing on understanding a few of the big ethical questions people have around AI.
December 4:Gather — NAIS, Boston
I’m thrilled for this reincarnation of PoCC and am glad to be sharing some work here…! 🙂
December 14: “Heads and CFOs: AI as Arrival Technology” — PAIS/PAISBOA, Hershey, PA
This joint membership meeting also includes Patrick Schuermann and Andy Van Schaack to facilitate heads and CFOs in a day exploring the question: What would need to be true to feel fully known, supported and strengthened as you face the headwinds of today and tomorrow, so the ‘power of the flock’ is behind you?
January 12: “Moving Your AI Conversation Forward” – SAIS Webinar, online
Does AI polarize your community? Join this webinar to gather tools for framing your community’s conversation so that different perspectives feel heard and you have the vocabulary to move forward together.
March 4: “Schools and AI: Running in Two Directions at Once” – NAIS Thrive, Baltimore
AI is pulling us ever further into technologically mediated experiences. Yet educators know the most powerful learning remains a social, human-to-human experience. The result is that schools must travel in both directions at once in order to continue providing the relational experiences excellent schools are known for while also preparing students for a technologically inundated world. I’m thrilled to lead this session with Indu Singh, in which we surface both high-level principles for navigating these seemingly divergent paths and also practical tools for the deliberate work of uniquely human thinking, learning, and relationship building.
Later events will be announced in future issues.
How do parents feel about AI in schools? Much more in the middle than our current discourse. See the posts in the AI Update for more detail.
“What happens when students move quickly across the written word, ping-ponging between multiple threads of surface content? And how does that compare to the act of immersing oneself in a long-form text that reveals a dynamic setting, complex characters, and an evolving plot—sometimes over hundreds of pages? We asked experts in literacy, cognition, and child development to weigh in. Here’s what they shared.”
“In their applications and in interviews, students expressed the urge to be forced to tackle classics they otherwise wouldn’t read, the need to combat frayed attention spans and the desire for an antidote to The Machine. Several mentioned with disdain that people who aren’t in the class wondered why they didn’t “just Chat the books,” i.e., use AI. “A lot of what we get out of this class is the human experience, and you can’t get that out of AI,” said Peggy Urdan, a government and neuroscience major from Lexington, Mass. “The only way to get anything out of this class is to not use AI.””
“Meyer makes a clear and pragmatic refusal to try to police student behavior on AI. He acknowledges the reality (backed up by data) that policing student use of AI outside of class is exhausting and can be costly to teacher-student relationships. Instead, he will assess what he can verify… There is an opportunity in all of this frustration and disruption: letting go of homework as a tool for compliance and holding on to its potential as a tool for learning… Meyer says homework will now be “complete/incomplete” and will count for 20% of the final grade. Students may use AI on their homework however they would like and that use will have no impact on whether the homework is assessed as “complete” or not.”
“If you put Thamus and Paul Graham side by side, their arguments are almost identical. Both warn that a new technology lets people skip the mental work and leaves them with only the appearance of understanding. The only difference is the villain. Twenty-four centuries ago it was writing, and today the people defending writing have given that role to AI. I don’t think that is a coincidence. The people who shape a debate about thinking are usually the people who are best at the dominant medium of their time. So they experience that medium as the place where their own thinking happens. For them, that is probably true. My problem is that they assume it is true for everybody else as well.”
“If you have a job that makes you sit at a desk most of the time, by the end of the workday you might feel stiff and exhausted. At that point, “it might seem overwhelming to drum up the energy to then go work out,” said Danielle Boles, a behavioral psychologist who studies the impact of mind-set on behavior. But what if you could flip that state of mind around? “The other mind-set would be, ‘I’ve been sitting all day, I cannot wait to move,’” Dr. Boles said. In both cases, she added, the situation is the same — only the framing is different. The mind-set you bring to exercise really matters. Simply adjusting yours can be an important step toward turning yourself into a consistent exerciser.”
“Because he should get lost in his own imagination, there should be a creek; because there should be a creek, the field should not be paved for the new athletic complex; because the field should not be paved, the school should not be in a facilities race with its rivals for amenities; because it should not race its rivals, it should not measure itself by the market; and because it should not measure itself by the market, it must remember what it is for.”
Four currents of social change from AI, parent perspectives, and more
Well, six weeks of AI news is a lifetime of news. This issue holds some of the highlights from the last month and a half.
In the five (5!) features, find more on the recent safety questions, some recent technical developments, and, most importantly (I believe), the reflection by the Rithm Project on the subtle ways AI is changing our social interactions. You’ve heard me say that this will be the most significant impact AI has on us. Not the job loss or the learning loss, but the changes to how we relate to each other socially and emotionally. The Rithm Project has identified four early subtle shifts: it blurring our sense of what is authentic and trustworthy; we are moving from building relationships through technology to building relationships with technology itself; AI is shaping our inner voice, changing how we understand and relate to ourselves; and AI is acting on our behalf, absorbing work that relationships are built on. This small nudges have large impacts at scale and over time. See the report for more.
Also in this issue, a survey of parents about what they hope schools will do about/with AI. The strength of this report is how much overlap it surfaces. See the image at the top of this issue.
Also, see responses from mathematicians to the extraordinary work AI had proposed in the math field.
These and more, enjoy!
Peter
How is AI subtly changing our social and emotional lives? See the report by the Rithm Project for more detail.
“So what can Sarah actually do, and why do I think every educator should at least know about this technology? Let’s start with the good and productive stuff. As I mentioned, Sarah has her own email account, and that is usually how I communicate with her. But I can also talk to her via WhatsApp or inside the Muse apps. Sarah reads my personal email, too, and keeps my personal inbox organized (not my work email; more on that later). You could say she acts like an advanced spam filter. But she does not stop there. She notices when I need to follow up on something and reminds me if I have not done it yet. She also has access to my calendar, knows what I have on tomorrow, and, if I ask her to, prepares a brief that outlines things like the purpose of each meeting and its anticipated outcomes.”
“It's a sunny day at the beach and you take a dip in the water to beat the heat. You float, you chat to a friend, you catch a wave. A little time passes and you head back to the shore only to realize you’re surprisingly far from your towel. Unknowingly, you’ve been pulled away by the current. This is the moment we find ourselves in with artificial intelligence... As the technology weaves into our daily lives, it is invisibly pulling on some of the most human parts of ourselves, including how we trust, care, and connect with one another.”
“To fight back, Americans need to learn the counterspy techniques of C.I.A. officers: using multiple sources to check information; testing those sources regularly for reliability; never getting complacent and trusting one source without thinking.”
“The AI safety community saw the incident through the lens of their long-running predictions about misalignment risks coming true. These risks had been dismissed as sci-fi scenarios by many people, and the community felt it was vindicated by these early incidents and used this opportunity to push for action by companies. On the other hand, the cybersecurity community compared the incident to the scale and scope of cyberattacks that they regularly deal with. It was clear that AI companies had not adopted a security mindset, nor had they implemented known control interventions when conducting these evaluations. In other words, the security community was taken aback when an incident that clearly resulted from negligence and largely did not lead to real-world harm led to so much commotion in the AI community.”
“On the very first page, Anthropic refers to a concept known as the “bitter lesson” — that when it comes to A.I. innovation, brute-force power will consistently replace handcrafted solutions… Famously, IBM’s chess-playing computer, Deep Blue, which used custom chips and supercomputer speed, beat the reigning world chess champion, Garry Kasparov, in 1997 by searching through 200 million chess positions per second. By 2017, Google DeepMind’s AlphaZero project had become even more generalized: Google fed the rules of chess to AlphaZero software, it played millions of games against itself, and it became extremely good at chess in about nine hours. This pattern — brute force replacing handcrafted solutions — proved itself out, decade after decade. That is the bitter lesson, a term coined in 2019 by the computer scientist Richard Sutton.”
“The question was simple: could Claude build an entire interactive Algebra 1 course on its own, in a day? ...On Saturday evening I typed one long request into my terminal. After that, my part was about half a dozen short replies. By the next morning, less than seven hours later, all 95 lessons were written, reviewed, narrated, and released.”
“You can pause procurement. You can pause access on a Chromebook. You cannot pause the impact these tools are already having on them everywhere else in their lives.”
“Asked about the net effect on their own child, parents rate social media at −24. AI comes in at +4, next to texting and the internet. Parents draw a hard line between the two. And when they do want Washington to act, it's for more protection, not a ban.”