Much of interest this week, including a new measure by the College Board to assess the adversity a student has experienced in life.
Also, an excellent synthesis about the effects of arts in society, a remarkable essay that offers a new and interesting take on the Shakespearean authorship debate (which I usually avoid), and a host of other provocative pieces.
Last, I've been thinking for a while about the relationship between self-directed learning and externally-driven standards. On the one hand, we should seek to foster intrinsic motivation in students. On the other, students also benefit by being held to rigorous standards (read: by learning to adapt to someone else's expectations and perspectives). I don't think these are necessarily in conflict, though. Balancing following the self and following others is a lifelong act, and it plays out in myriad ways, especially in education. Bearing this in mind, the discussion about learning styles needs more nuance. See the article in cognitive science as an example of one perspective. Generally, the dialogue on this topic seems to claim that either learning styles are bunk or they are the treasured nature of every individual. And in all these, what is meant by "learning styles" (and the implication for what is to be done with them) is as vague and unclearly defined as "personalized learning."
We need more discussion articulating when, why, and how the balance between intrinsic and extrinsic forces in education ought to be kept.
Enjoy this and other reading!
Peter
New York Times · 05/17/19
“The dehumanizing message of the new adversity index is that America’s young people are nothing but interchangeable sociological points of data — and the jagged complexity of an individual life somehow can be sanded down, quantified and fairly contrasted.”
Pacific Standard · 05/09/19
New York Times · 05/11/19
“Students are affected by more than just the quality of a lesson plan. They also respond to the passion of their teachers and the engagement of their peers, and they seek a sense of purpose. They benefit from specific instructions, constant feedback and a culture of learning that encourages resilience in the face of failure — not unlike a football practice. There are many ways to be an effective teacher, just as there are many ways to be an effective coach. But all good teachers, like good coaches, communicate that they care about your goals.”
Scientific American · 05/16/19
“In fact, teens who only made it through high school but were raised in a bookish environment fared as well in adulthood as college grads who grew up in a house bereft of books.”
Scientific American · 05/17/19
“This is an important shift to dissect because whether we tell our stories primarily from a sociological or psychological point of view has great consequences for how we deal with our world and the problems we encounter.”
Chronicle of Higher Education · 05/07/19