An extraordinary week of research syntheses.
On grading and commenting, on types of knowledge, on testing, on sleep, and more -- this week offers helpful distillations of what we know about certain essential components of teaching & learning:
The first feature article on grades and comments offers an excellent summary of the research on assessment feedback. Note that the conclusions of the article are more than simply what is mentioned in the blurb -- look also at the how the nature of the feedback helps, including a summary of what goals comments ought to accomplish. Missing from the article, unfortunately, is the effect of comments alone -- it explores grades and comments together, and arrives at some surprising conclusions.
And the second feature offers what I think is a critical reminder that "research-backed" has limited application in education (not zero, but limited). Every classroom is different, so randomized-controlled trials can't account for the variability of each classroom. Because of this, practitioner research -- practitioner knowledge -- helps fill out an understanding of what works, and why. Building research models not only around standard scientific methods, but also around improvement science honors both traditional research formats and practitioner expertise.
Enjoy these and other articles this week, including insight into "cancel culture" among adolescents, which is not what I thought it was at first.
Peter Nilsson
King's Academy
Jordan
Hechinger Report · 10/24/19
The 74 Million · 10/23/19
“A study last year raised questions about the extent of the gap, but the science is clear that children’s first three years are the most critical time for brain development."
Scientific American · 10/29/19
Model View Culture · 10/07/14
Publishers Weekly · 10/25/19
New York Times · 10/28/19