The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #386 (July 17, 2022)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

An excellent week.

The feature article on good teaching explores a familiar tension: engagement versus achievement. Rhetoric seems to tend towards one or the other, depending on who is speaking. How can we achieve both? This piece offers insight.

Also, the feature piece from the Center for Curriculum Redesign offers guidance on how academic leaders might focus skill development across the curriculum. Explore the pdf report for a detailed mapping of how competencies are developed across disciplines.

Elsewhere in this issue, see Larry Cuban's continued work on the value of peer-to-peer teacher classroom observations, several pieces on the value of movement in learning, and two different articles on when messaging or emailing friends can be most valuable and why you should avoid emails and messaging when at work.

These and more: enjoy!

Peter Nilsson
King's Academy
Jordan

FEATURED

Which Disciplines Focus Most On Which Competencies

Center for Curriculum Redesign · 06/01/21

“Every discipline has a key role to play for development of Competency expertise and transfer. If all disciplines focus on teaching their top Competencies, benefits will exist at the curricular, course, and learner level. Curricula will be integrated with relevant Competencies which will in turn increase content relevance and depth of understanding of what it means to proactively practice and contribute to each field. At the same time, teachers will feel less pressure to cover all the Competencies beyond their content area, by either addressing one cursorily or otherwise cognitively overloading learners.”

On Good Teaching: Can We Have Both High Achievement And High Engagement?

Hechinger Report · 07/11/22

“The academics found that there was often a tradeoff between “good teaching” where kids learn stuff and “good teaching” that kids enjoy. Teachers who were good at raising test scores tended to receive low student evaluations. Teachers with great student evaluations tended not to raise test scores all that much… It was rare, but the researchers managed to find six teachers among the 53 in the study that could do both types of good teaching simultaneously. Teachers who incorporated a lot of hands-on, active learning received high marks from students and raised test scores. These teachers often had students working together collaboratively in pairs or groups, using tactile objects to solve problems or play games. For example, one teacher had students use egg cartons and counters to find equivalent fractions. These doubly “good” teachers had another thing in common: they maintained orderly classrooms that were chock full of routines.”

ADMISSIONS

“Admissions Without Applications”

Inside Higher Ed · 07/11/22

“In the fall, the college plans to consider some students who haven’t actually applied for admission at all. They will be students who have created profiles through Sage Scholars, which has offered a service since 1995 to help students afford college. This year, in addition to presenting students whom colleges might want to recruit to apply, Sage will also offer some of its several hundred members the chance to look at the profiles (which will contain the interests, grades and test scores of students who have them) and admit students directly… By creating a profile, “you are just saying ‘I’m interested in college.’”

Does Going Test-Optional Actually Change Admissions Outcomes?

Hechinger Report · 07/13/22

CREATIVITY

“Humor Boosts Creativity”

John Spencer · 09/16/19

One Way Of Defining Innovation (In Business)

McKinsey · 07/15/22

CURRICULUM

More Schools Are Teaching Students About Personal Finance

CNBC · 07/08/22

“I was present as the students’ teacher, Marina White, demonstrated the power of investing and compound interest. “This one decision, to give up a couple Starbucks every weekend and each morning you walk in here, can make you a millionaire by the time you retire,” she says. Many of White’s students are “in shock” when they learn that their behavior and choices can so strongly influence their financial future.”

On Emotional Literacy As A Key Skill For Students

Deseret News · 07/13/22

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

On Code-Switching And Supporting Multi-Language Classrooms

Cult of Pedagogy · 07/10/22

“Not all students feel they can bring their whole selves into the classroom. Even the most well-meaning teachers can unwittingly do more harm than good. Many bicultural and bilingual children report experiencing a sense of loss when they acquire their second language (Casesa, 2013) and it’s not by coincidence that their educational setting plays a part in this.”

Rubrics Can Mitigate Bias In Hiring

Inside Higher Ed · 07/12/22

HEALTH

Close Friends Are A Key To Good Mental Health. But How Many?

New York Times · 06/10/22

“If your goal is simply to mitigate the harmful impact loneliness can have on your health, what matters most is having at least one important person in your life — whether that’s a partner, a parent, a friend or someone else, said Jeffrey Hall, a professor of communication studies at the University of Kansas. “Going from zero to one is where we get the most bang for your buck, so to speak,” Dr. Hall said. “But if you want to have the most meaningful life, one where you feel bonded and connected to others, more friends are better.””

A Mental Health Checklist For Heading To College

New York Times · 07/08/22

HUMANITIES

Reading Literary Fiction Leads To A More Complex World View

Literary Hub · 07/08/22

“Interestingly, the finding was specific to literary fiction as a genre. In fact, the authors found that “early-life reading of narrative fiction that presents more standardized plots and characters, such as romance novels, predict holding a less complex worldview.” …The key to a complex worldview, the authors argue, is not exactly about empathy, as other studies would have it, but about internalizing the concept of difference.”

Ada Limón Is The Next US Poet Laureate

New York Times · 07/12/22

LEADERSHIP

On Networking For Leaders: Operational, Personal, Strategic

Harvard Business Review · 01/01/07

8 Ways Teachers Need More Support From Leaders

Harvard Graduate School of Education · 07/01/22

Four Elements Of Leading WIth Heart To Build Purpose-Driven Performance

NAIS · 07/12/22

LEARNING SCIENCE

Growth Mindset Interventions Work Best When Class Practices Support Them

Research Gate · 10/01/21

“Direct-to-student, computer-delivered growth mindset interventions have shown promise as a way to improve achievement for those at risk of failing in school; however, these interventions only benefit students who happen to be in classrooms that support growth mindset beliefs.”

Move, Move, Movement. Motor Memories Are Encoded Differently

Stanford · 07/08/22

“These findings suggest that, in addition to being dispersed, motor memories are highly redundant. The researchers say that as we repeat learned skills, we are continually reinforcing the motor engrams by building new connections — refining the skill. It’s what is meant by the term muscle memory — a refined, highly redundant network of motor engrams used so frequently that the associated skill seems automatic.”

More On How Movement Can Aid Learning

KQED · 06/29/21

“The Brain Has A Low Power Mode That Blunts Our Senses”

Wired · 07/10/22

PD

On Teachers Watching Colleagues Teaching (Part 1)

Larry Cuban · 07/12/22

“Surely, observing a fellow teacher elsewhere in the school or the district for a few lessons followed up with a discussion–without making judgments of a “good” or “bad” lesson—offers a splendid opportunity to learn new and, perhaps, better ways to carry off a reading, math, or science lesson while interacting with students. Teachers learning from teachers is an under-used resource in “professional development,” the jargony term for teacher improvement.”

On Teachers Watching Colleagues Teaching (Part 2)

Larry Cuban · 07/16/22

“Uncommon as it may be, encouraging teachers to collaborate by observing one another lets these solo practitioners to learn from one another through comparing and contrasting their ways of teaching lessons. Doing so reduces teacher isolation and insulation baked into the age-graded structure of one teacher with one group of students in classrooms arrayed along hallways plowing through a packed daily schedule. From solo practitioner to collaborative practitioner, then, becomes more than a dream. Such a return on investment may far outstrip the time costs.”

PEDAGOGY

"4 Shifts To Move From Teacher Centered To Learner Centered”

Katie L. Martin · 01/13/19

On Helping Students Practice Saying And Hearing The Word “No”

Edutopia · 07/11/22

SOCIAL MEDIA

Short, Text, Check-Ins With Friends Make An Outsize Difference

New York Times · 222-07-11

STEM

DALL-E And Whether AI-Generated Art Will Replace Human Art

Wired · 07/13/22

“The project helped convince him that image-generating AI will lead to an explosion of creativity that permanently changes humanity’s visual environment. “Anything that can have a visual will have one,” he says, potentially upending people’s intuition for judging how much time or effort was expended on a project. “Suddenly we have this tool that makes what was hard to imagine and visualize easy to make exist.” It's too early to know how such a transformative technology will ultimately affect illustrators, photographers, and other creatives. But at this point, the idea that artistic AI tools will displace workers from creative jobs—in the way that people sometimes describe robots replacing factory workers—appears to be an oversimplification.”

“How A Public School In Florida Built America’s Greatest Math Team”

Wall Street Journal · 07/14/22

Extraordinary Images And Lessons From The James Webb Telescope

New York Times · 07/15/22

TECH

McKinsey’s Primer On The Metaverse

McKinsey · 07/15/22

WORKPLACE

Looping: “Staying With The Same Teacher The Following Year Benefits Students”

KQED · 06/29/22

““It’s not a magic bullet, but it does seem to have a positive effect,” Wedenoja said. “I think it also says something larger about the fact that relationships between teachers and students are important.””

Stop Emailing: Pick Up The Phone Or Visit Your Colleague

Fast Company · 07/11/22

“A survey by the communication platform Loom of more than 3,000 office workers found that 91% have had digital messages misunderstood or misinterpreted at work, and for 20%, the misinterpretation has caused them to get reprimanded, demoted, or even fired… In contrast, face-to-face conversations or video calls allow for more layers of meaning to be conveyed between and among parties. “Aspects of a message such as emotion, tone, sense of urgency, or sarcasm can be more easily conveyed in these communication-rich channels,” says Dalton.”

GENERAL

On Having A Piano In The House

Austin Kleon · 12/02/20

How To Quit Helicopter Parenting

Atlantic · 05/10/22

Audubon Announces Its 2022 Photography Award Winners

Audobon · 07/01/22

"In Praise Of Pointless Goals”

Atlantic · 07/09/22

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →