The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #402 (December 11, 2022)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

What a week.

The story of the week, without a doubt, was the emergence of OpenAI's chatbot. This transformative technology has spawned a thousand think pieces, and rightfully so. See an overview of the tool -- and some of the extraordinary things it can do -- in the featured article. But also look at sections throughout this issue for other articles about A.I.

Separately, the other feature article explores the suggestion that teaching improves over the first three years, but then plateaus after that. Like many grand statements, it's not really accurate, but it has grains of truth. See the post for more of how we actually grow during our teaching careers.

For lighter fare, enjoy the two pieces in the language section on the words of the year, or enjoy this week's final article: the 2022 Comedy Wildlife Photography winners.

Enjoy!

Peter Nilsson
King's Academy
Jordan

FEATURED

Does Experience Matter?

Education Endowment Foundation · 09/08/20

“There has been a longstanding belief in education that, after the early years of their career, a teacher’s experience has little to no influence on their ability to help pupils learn (Rice, 2003; Hanushek and Luque, 2003; Rockoff, 2004). It has been thought that teachers undergo a steep learning curve upon entering the profession, lasting three to five years, before plateauing for the remainder of their careers (Rivkin et al, 2005)… However, some more recent research appears to contradict this longstanding hypothesis. In their review of US research published on this subject since 2003, Podolsky et al (2019) suggest that effectiveness increases throughout a teacher’s career… In their review of 30 studies, Podolsky et al find that, after a steep initial incline upon entering the profession, teachers tend to follow an upward trajectory of effectiveness that continues into the second, and at times third decade of teaching.”

What Is This New AI Chatbot, In Brief?

New York Times · 12/05/22

“ChatGPT is, quite simply, the best artificial intelligence chatbot ever released to the general public… For most of the past decade, A.I. chatbots have been terrible — impressive only if you cherry-pick the bot’s best responses and throw out the rest. In recent years, a few A.I. tools have gotten good at doing narrow and well-defined tasks, like writing marketing copy, but they still tend to flail when taken outside their comfort zones… But ChatGPT feels different. Smarter. Weirder. More flexible. It can write jokes (some of which are actually funny), working computer code and college-level essays. It can also guess at medical diagnoses, create text-based Harry Potter games and explain scientific concepts at multiple levels of difficulty."

ADOLESCENCE

“Teens Are Struggling With Climate Anxiety”

EdWeek · 12/07/22

““I don’t know anybody my age who’s like, ‘Yeah, I want to have kids,’” said… a 15-year-old junior.”

CHARACTER

Do Growth Mindsets Matter? Meta-Analyses Offer Up Discussion

KQED · 12/05/22

CREATIVITY

“The Art Of Imperfection”

Austin Kleon · 12/02/22

Schedule Time For Creativity. Our Days Allow Less Time For Thinking

Cal Newport · 12/05/22

Austin Kleon On His Dream Work Studio

Austin Kleon · 12/06/22

ELEMENTARY

Primary Schools Embrace Explicit Instruction — And Thrive

Sydney Morning Herald · 12/04/22

HEALTH

“Everyone Is Sick Right Now”

Wired · 12/07/22

HUMANITIES

Americans Disagree Less Than People Think On How History Should Be Taught

EdWeek · 12/07/22

“Many Republicans believe most Democrats want to teach a history defined by shameful oppression and white guilt. Many Democrats believe most Republicans want to focus on the white majority and overlook slavery and racism. But we found that both impressions are wrong.”

“Why Do We Care About Literary Characters?” (Real Or Fictional)

Stanford · 12/07/22

LANGUAGE

OED 2022 Word Of The Year: “Goblin Mode”

New York Times · 12/04/22

Five Different 2022 Words Of The Year

BuzzFeed · 12/06/22

LEADERSHIP

Leadership, The Pandemic, And Imposter Syndrome

ASCD · 11/30/22

“This school year in particular, it seems like every interaction between teachers and administrators is contentious. Most leaders have done their level best to respond to the malaise sweeping through the teaching profession… Still, teaching is such a demanding profession that these measures seem meretricious, even insulting. On top of that, an education leader’s job is not merely to respond to teachers’ problems, but to enact innovation. Pushing for change now , of all times, can make you feel like a monster—a sociopathic tyrant bludgeoning hardworking teachers with unwanted initiatives. If you had impostor syndrome before, it’s most likely on overdrive these days.”

Fight Your Ego: It Is The Enemy Of Good Leadership

Harvard Business Review · 11/06/22

Use Videos (TikTok?) To Communicate With Your Students, Team

EdWeek · 12/01/22

More On How To Use Video Tools To Communicate

EdWeek · 12/02/22

How To Set Up A Systematic Hiring Process

Startup Real Talk · 12/07/22

LEARNING SCIENCE

MRIs Can See Learning Happening

TES · 12/05/22

Daniel Willingham Is On TikTok, Teaching Study Skills

TikTok · 12/06/22

PEDAGOGY

Three Tips For Expressing Yourself In Order To Be Understood

Big Think · 12/01/22

A One Page Poster Describing Think-Pair-Share

Jamie Lee Clark · 12/10/22

READING/WRITING

“How Children Are Taught To Read Faces A Reckoning”

WBUR · 12/05/22

“Colorado’s law - passed in 2019 - is pretty extensive. It requires school districts to completely overhaul their reading curriculum. As of this school year, all districts must use an “evidence and scientifically based” reading program, teachers all have to go through 45 hours of training on it, and they even banned curriculum rooted in balanced literacy.”

Twitter Thread On Teaching Writing In An Age Of A.I.

Twitter · 12/03/22

SOCIAL MEDIA

On TikTok, Misinformation, And Teenage Attention

EdSurge · 12/07/22

““The TikTok algorithm is designed for doomscrolling,” Volland says. “Being so overwhelmed by the volume of information makes it harder to be able to distinguish high- from low-quality content. It can make us feel more anxious, and we should be cognizant of that for young people who are spending so much time on the platform.””

STEM

Anthony Fauci Reflects On His Career

New York Times · 12/10/22

“I share my story, one of love of science and discovery, in hopes of inspiring the next generation to enter health-related careers — and to stay the course, regardless of challenges and surprises that might arise.”

McKinsey’s Five Year Review Of A.I. Growth

McKinsey · 12/06/22

TECH

On Coming To Terms With A.I. Writing: A Historical, Philosophical View

Hedgehog Review · 11/23/22

Krugman: Technology Doesn’t Replace Jobs, It Changes Them

New York Times · 12/06/22

WORKPLACE

“When Algorithms Rule, Values Can Wither”

MIT Sloan Management Review · 12/05/22

“How can managers and organizations that need or want to leverage these technologies protect multiple values in their decisions and routines to avoid the tyranny of technique? We propose that adhering to three principles can help: 1) Beware of proxies and scaling effects. 2) Strategically insert human interventions into your algorithmic decision-making. 3) Create evaluative systems that account for multiple values. We’ll look more closely at each of these principles below.”

Hybrid Work Schedules: What Do People Want? What Works Best?

Gallup · 11/07/22

GenZ In The Workplace: What Does The Data Say?

Gallup · 11/11/22

7 Keys To Promoting Retention In On Site Workers

Gallup · 11/15/22

On The Dangers Of Gamification

New Republic · 12/07/22

GENERAL

On The Future Of ISTE And ASCD

K12 Dive · 12/05/22

Comedy Wildlife Photography: 2022 Winners

IFL Science · 12/08/22

On Wikipedia, Twitter, And Elon Musk

Vice · 12/08/22

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →