The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #404 (January 22, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Another extraordinary week.

Educators continue to probe the opportunities and limits of this new A.I. technology. Here at King's, we have set aside time in each of our first three faculty meetings to explore both new opportunities for learning (idea generation, writing co-pilot) and new threats to learning (academic integrity, college essays) presented by ChatGPT.

This week's first feature explores the future of writing in this new world, and while the tone of the essay is cynical, it offers some provocative reflections on how ChatGPT might move into the professional world. As a balance to the author's cynicism, I'm reminded that we still teach and practice handwriting in an age of computer keyboards, and we still teach math by hand in an age of calculators. We will still need to teach and practice writing in schools and in our professional lives, but it will happen differently, in different times and in different ways.

The second feature summarizes new research about debate and argument. It suggests that "arguing to learn" rather "arguing to win" increases growth and ultimate success later on. This is a meaningful selection for times of greater polarization.

Later in the issue find two sections on AI (now back in the tech section). Also find several unusual takes in the diversity and inclusion section, a summary of research on the 4-day work week, and predictions from 1923 about what 2023 would be like.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

On ChatGPT: “AI Is The End Of Writing”

The Spectator · 01/10/23

“It’s at this point that the usual essay on ChatGPT points towards something consoling. Something like ‘Ah, but do not despair, humans will always yada yada’. I’m afraid I am not here to offer any such solace. I’ve done writing of all kinds for several decades, from travel journalism to art journalism to political journalism, from literary fiction to youthful memoirs to notorious-letters-to-No-10 to Fifty Shades porn (a pseudonym) to, lately, religious or domestic thrillers. And I have to say: we are screwed. By which I mean: we, the writers. We’re screwed. Writing is over. That’s it. It’s time to pack away your quill, your biro, and your shiny iPad: the computers will soon be here to do it better.”

How We Debate: Highly Successful People Argue Differently

CNBC · 01/19/23

“Instead of trying to “win” every argument you find yourself in, you could have more success if you look at arguments as opportunities to learn and grow… The setup was simple: Participants had to debate hot-button topics in an online chatroom. One group was instructed to adopt a competitive mentality in order to “win” the argument, while the other group was told to “argue to learn.” An “arguing to learn” mentality rests in viewing contentious conversations as collaborative exchanges that can deepen your understanding of a given topic, rather than battles to be won.”

ATHLETICS

How Safe Are Bicycle Helmets?

Slate · 01/16/23

CHARACTER

More Examinations Of Whether/How Growth Mindsets Work

KQED · 12/05/22

“How A Bit Of Awe Can Improve Your Health”

New York Times · 01/03/23

Sighing Is An Effective Stress Reduction Technique

Cell Reports · 01/10/23

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

"The Case For A Commission On Boys And Men”

Brookings · 01/13/23

“It’s possible to believe that sexism remains a major impediment to women’s flourishing and also believe that for many boys and men life is much harder than it should be. . . Even if you’re not inclined to care much about men’s welfare, their growing anomie and resentment is everyone’s problem, fueling right-wing populist movements around the world. People who feel unmoored and demeaned are going to be receptive to the idea that the natural order of things has been upended, the core claim of reactionary politics.”

“What Educators Of Color Say It Will Take To Boost Their Numbers In School Leadership”

EdWeek · 01/17/23

“What If Diversity Trainings Are Doing More Harm Than Good?”

New York Times · 01/17/23

HIGHER ED

More College Closures Expected As Population Drops

Hechinger Report · 01/13/23

LANGUAGE

Feeling Crambazzled? Case Of The Mubble-Fubbles? Here’s To Good Old Words.

CBC · 01/14/23

LEADERSHIP

“What Principals Can Learn Riding The Bus”

Edutopia · 01/10/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

Our Environment Affects Our Decision-Making

Character Lab · 01/15/23

“Even the smallest differences can have an outsized effect. In one study, researchers moved items from the front to the back of a salad bar—a change of just 10 inches—and the slight inconvenience prompted people to eat less of these items.”

READING/WRITING

Encoding, The Equal And Opposite Side Of Decoding

EdWeek · 01/17/23

STEM

The Pace Of Scientific Breakthroughs Has Been Slowing For 75 Years

New York Times · 01/17/23

TECH

“3D Printed Homes Level Up With A 2-Story House In Houston”

NPR · 01/16/23

WORKPLACE

On Doing Work When Everyone Is Angry

Harvard Business Review · 11/09/22

Detailed Research: Does The 4-Day Week Work?

RAND Corporation · 12/01/22

GENERAL

“183 Ways The World Got Better In 2022.”

Reasons to be Cheerful · 12/30/22

What People In 1923 Predicted About 2023

Medium · 01/11/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

On What Turing Tests Mean In A World With The New Chatbots

New York Times · 01/20/23

“Certainly, these bots will change the world. But the onus is on you to be wary of what these systems say and do, to edit what they give you, to approach everything you see online with skepticism. Researchers know how to give these systems a wide range of skills, but they do not yet know how to give them reason or common sense or a sense of truth. That still lies with you.”

Researcher Trains ChatBot On Her Childhood Journals, Talks To Her Younger Self

Twitter · 11/28/22

One Professor's Assignment For Getting To Know ChatGPT

Dropbox · 01/15/23

What Are Microsoft’s Plans For OpenAI And ChatGPT?

Quartz · 01/17/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

One Professor’s ChatGPT Policy

Twitter · 01/16/23

“19 Ways To Use ChatGPT In Your Classroom”

EdWeek · 01/18/23

Teacher Offers Flash Fiction Competition To Students, Using ChatGPT

Mr. Pultz · 01/18/23

TECH/AI: GOVERNMENT AND LAW

Lawsuits Begin For Intellectual Ownership Of A.I. Generated Art

ArtNet · 01/12/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →