The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #417 (July 30, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

An excellent week.

Two headlines for this week's issue:

First, see the short essay below for a longer reflection on this moment as it related to A.I. and education. The A.I. world has changed significantly since May, and it's important that schools be prepared.

But also, second, there are major developments outside of tech: legacy admissions is coming under scrutiny, July has been the hottest month in the history of recorded weather, recent research has parsed the efficacy of parent involvement, and more.

In other topics, I'm a particular fan of the podcast by Adam Grant with Ed Catmull from Pixar about creative cultures, and I greatly appreciated the recent Radiolab podcast (and earlier Scientific American article) on the case for how disabilities can become advantages when understood in a different context.

Thanks for reading -- I hope this issue is helpful at this pivotal time. If you find it useful, consider sharing it with colleagues, and if you'd like to subscribe new colleagues to your school, don't hesitate to reach out.

Enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

Harvard Student Best Shows Reality Of ChatGPT In Schools. Get Ready.

Slow Boring · 07/18/23

“ChatGPT has made cheating so simple — and for now, so hard to catch — that I expect many students will use it when writing essays. Currently about 60% of college students admit to cheating in some form, and last year 30% used ChatGPT for schoolwork. That was only in the first year of the model’s launch to the public. As it improves and develops a reputation for high-quality writing, this usage will increase. Next year, if college students are willing to use ChatGPT-4, they should be able to get passing grades on all of their essays with almost no work. In other words, ChatGPT-4 will eliminate Ds and Fs in the humanities and social sciences. And that’s only eight months after its release to the public — the technology is rapidly improving.”

“What If America Had A National Conversation Skills Curriculum?”

Intrepid News · 07/26/23

“Our conversation crisis has manifested in eye-watering political polarity. This bitter partisanship is not new, but fresh research has documented how it interferes with learning on college campuses and ultimately, decreases young adults’ faith in the power of communicating across differences. Their jadedness — and lack of ability and willingness to use conversation as a mechanism for compromise — is a fundamental threat to our democracy.”

ADMISSIONS

Legacy Admissions Now In The Crosshairs

New York Times · 07/25/23

“The Education Department has opened a civil rights investigation into Harvard University’s legacy admissions policy, inserting the federal government directly into a fierce national debate about wealth, privilege and race after the Supreme Court gutted the use of affirmative action in higher education… The Education Department’s Office of Civil Rights has powerful enforcement authority that could eventually lead to a settlement with Harvard or trigger a lengthy legal battle like the one that led to the Supreme Court’s decision to severely limit race-conscious admissions last month, reversing a decades-long approach that had increased chances for Black students and those from other minority groups.”

Data On Wealth And Admissions: “Affirmative Action For The Rich”

New York Times · 07/24/23

“How Big Is The Legacy Boost At Elite Colleges?”

New York Times · 07/27/23

ADOLESCENCE

Is Play Deprivation A Major Cause Of The Teen Mental Health Crisis?

Jonathan Haidt · 07/27/23

“He then shows how we have systematically deprived children of free play since the 1970s and shows that adolescents' mental health has declined substantially over the same period. He notes that this is a correlation, not proof of causation, although experiments with animals support the claim that play deprivation causes anxiety and poor social development.”

CHARACTER

A Failure Resume: And A Reminder That Failure Can Mean Growth

Larry Cuban · 07/24/23

“For me, however, closed doors did two things. In some instances, I doubled down and persisted—50 rejections in applying for superintendent posts—in other instances, it nudged me to open doors that I had not considered–going from the failed attempt to manage a governmental research group riven by racial animosities to administering the Office of Staff Development in the Washington, D.C. schools or getting rejected for a principalship and deciding to pursue a doctorate.”

CURRICULUM

“Paving The Path For ‘Blue-Collar AI’ Professionals”

Myra Roldan · 07/23/23

“AI systems are taking on repetitive, physically demanding, or hazardous roles, allowing human workers to engage in more intricate tasks — this is where the term “blue-collar AI” comes in, these are roles that do not require the individual to have deep data science skills, be a researcher, or to build complex algorithms. “Blue-collar AI” professionals work within existing AI Infrastructures maintaining, integrating, using, and optimizing these systems.”

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

“The Case For Disabled Astronauts”

Scientific American · 05/30/18

Alison Bechdel And The Origin Of The Bechdel Test For Films

Guardian · 07/02/23

“The Right Stuff” - On How Disability Can Become An Advantage (Podcast)

Radiolab · 07/21/23

“How To Effectively — And Legally — Use Racial Data For DEI”

Harvard Business Review · 07/24/23

HIGHER ED

High Schools Account For Nearly 1 In 5 Community College Students

Hechinger Report · 07/24/23

“Dual enrollment far exceeds the popularity of Advanced Placement courses”

HUMANITIES

Is The Arrival Of A.I. Another Oppenheimer Moment?

New York Times · 07/25/23

“We have now arrived at a similar crossroads in the science of computing, a crossroads that connects engineering and ethics, where we will again have to choose whether to proceed with the development of a technology whose power and potential we do not yet fully apprehend… It was the raw power and strategic potential of the bomb that prompted their call to action then. It is the far less visible but equally significant capabilities of these newest artificial intelligence technologies that should prompt swift action now.”

The “Oldest Named Poet”, A Sumerian Woman, Writes Of Change

Aeon · 07/28/23

“Enheduana does not offer clear answers to these questions, and I would not hold her up as a model for good living in difficult times. But her poems fascinate me in part because they describe, with dazzling intensity, a world where change is the norm. These are poems from, and about, unstable times. That is one reason I am drawn to them: I want to understand what it means to live in such a world, because I will probably have to.”

LEADERSHIP

Adam Grant Interviews Ed Catmull Of Pixar About Creative Cultures

Rethinking · 07/25/23

“You don’t actually reach the stable point, because there is no stable point. A successful group is fundamentally unstable. If you recognize the instability, that means, ok, we are continually adapting and changing. And when something doesn’t go the way you thought it was going to go, ok, what do we do? But that’s what we apply to life. To everything we’re doing. Ok, let’s take on the next problem, because they’re coming. What do we do when they come?”

“Don’t Judge Past Decisions Based On New Information” (re: COVID)

Uncharted Territories · 07/23/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

Reminder: People Can’t Multitask

New York Times · 07/29/23

SOCIAL MEDIA

On The Conflict Between Social Media And Our Cognitive Development

Intrepid News · 07/25/23

SUSTAINABILITY

“July Is Globe's Hottest Month In Recorded History”

PBS · 07/27/23

WORKPLACE

Parent Involvement Improves Student Outcomes

EdWeek · 07/25/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

An Early-AI Reflection That Got It Right (From Dec. 2022)

Noahpinion · 12/01/22

“What’s common to all of these visions is something we call the “sandwich” workflow. This is a three-step process. First, a human has a creative impulse, and gives the AI a prompt. The AI then generates a menu of options. The human then chooses an option, edits it, and adds any touches they like.”

“On Holding Back The Strange A.I. Tide”

One Useful Thing · 07/23/23

“There is no way for [schools] to harness this kind of power and creativity without, in some way, democratizing control over AI. Only innovation driven by [teachers] can actually radically transform [learning], because only [teachers] can experiment enough on their own tasks to learn how to use AI in transformative ways… We have considerable agency about how to use AI in our work, schools, and societies, but we need to start with the presumption that we are facing genuine, and widespread, disruption across many fields. The scientists and engineers designing AI, as capable as they are, have no particular expertise on how AI can best be used, or even how and when it should be used. We get to make those decisions. But we have to recognize that the AI tide is rising, and that the time to decide what that means is now.”

Longread: On Writing In An Age Of A.I.

Noema · 07/25/23

“What makes good writing in a world with generative AI? Perhaps writing classes of the future will lean into the subtle ways in which human writing surpasses AI-generated writing and challenge students to write better than the machine… But perhaps ChatGPT also shows us that at a certain point, reading has diminishing returns. Maybe we also need to be trained on other kinds of data in order to write well, data that comes from being alive in the world over time, from accumulating enough experience to differentiate our own voice from others.”

Screen-less A.I. - The Star Trek Ultimate Translator Is Now Real

TED · 07/01/23

AI Can Predict What Artwork You Will Remember

Advanced Science News · 07/11/23

Survey: 44% Of Teens Are “Likely” To Use A.I. To Do Their Schoolwork

EdWeek · 07/26/23

What Is The Digital And A.I. Transformation Playbook?

McKinsey · 07/27/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

“Encode Justice” A HS And College Student-Led Group Focused On A.I. Ethics

Politico · 05/01/23

“Encode Justice emerged from that ballot campaign with a focus on the use of AI algorithms in surveillance and the criminal justice system. It currently boasts a membership of 600 high school and college students across 30 countries. Revanur said the group’s primary source of funding currently comes from the Omidyar Network, a self-described “social change venture” led by left-leaning eBay founder Pierre Omidyar.”

Very Brief Introduction To An A.I. Themed School

EdWeek · 07/24/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →