Educator’s Notebook #419 (August 13, 2023)
← Previous Issue · Next Issue →
An excellent week—
Congratulations to those who are already starting up with classes and orientations!
This week’s feature articles focus first on recent research suggesting that with the right scaffolding for conversation, citizens can more easily build bridges across their differences, even when the divide appears large. See the post for what makes this possible, and how we might set these conditions in schools. Also find in the features a post on how we can augment our creativity and innovation with A.I. tools.
Also this week to stay abreast of sustainability efforts, explore the recent collection of articles on renewable energy in the US, including how and why adoption is accelerating — but also why there’s a surprising growing opposition among… environmentalists.
In teaching & learning, see a primer on how academic standards support schools, see examples of what teaching black history looks like in three cities, and more, including featured learning materials, which focus on the African diaspora.
Much more in A.I. this week “below the fold” as the old journalism adage used to go. See especially several posts about turning points in A.I. development.
Enjoy!
Peter
FEATURED
America In One Room · 08/01/23
“The Stanford Deliberative Democracy Lab, in collaboration with Helena and various partners has conducted a national Deliberative Poll® to determine what Americans would really think about possible reforms to our democracy and our electoral processes if they had a chance to weigh the options under good conditions… What would Americans really think if they could discuss the issues in depth in moderated small group discussions with fellow citizens, if they had access to vetted and balanced briefing materials, and if they could get their questions answered by panels of competing experts representing different points of view? NORC at the University of Chicago convened a national sample of nearly 600 deliberators and a separate control group to consider reform proposals from across the political spectrum.”
One Useful Thing · 08/13/23
“Reading these studies, it seems like there are a few clear conclusions: AI can generate creative ideas in real-life, practical situations. It can also help people generate better ideas. The ideas AI generates are better than what most people can come up with, but very creative people will beat the AI (at least for now), and may benefit less from using AI to generate ideas. There is more underlying similarity in the ideas that the current generation of AIs produce than among ideas generated by a large number of humans. All of this suggests that humans still have a large role to play in innovation… but that they would be foolish not to include AI in that process, especially if they don’t consider themselves highly creative.”
ASSESSMENT
EdWeek · 07/31/23
“The movement for high academic standards—determinations of what students should know and be able to do across subjects and grade levels—promised to center teaching and learning on common themes across schools and raise expectations for all students. Standards have shaped the teaching and learning landscape in American schools, dictating everything from curriculum content to assessment design. They have also been, and continue to be, a site of controversy and political battles… In this explainer, Education Week breaks down what standards are, how they have come to occupy such a central place in the U.S. education system, and how they have—and have not—changed instructional practice and student outcomes.”
ATHLETICS
New York Times · 08/09/23
CREATIVITY
Kottke · 08/10/23
“Moment to moment feedback may be enough to motivate deep engagement.”
CURRICULUM
Next Gen Learning · 06/08/23
Hechinger Report · 08/07/23
HEALTH
New York Times · 08/09/23
“I interviewed dozens of independent scientists studying respiratory health whom I’ve known for years, and they all agreed that schools should primarily do two things.”
New York Times · 08/09/23
““It’s the best medicine we can recommend: Just going out for a walk,” said Dr. Randal Thomas, a preventive cardiology specialist at the Mayo Clinic who was not involved with the study.”
New York Times · 08/11/23
HUMANITIES
Renegade Intellectual · 08/11/23
New York Times · 08/13/23
LANGUAGE
New York Times · 08/09/23
LEADERSHIP
Stanford · 08/01/23
“A personality of a leader that might work in one situation might be exactly the wrong personality in another situation.”
Harvard Business Review · 01/21/22
Wall Street Journal · 08/10/23
PD
PEDAGOGY
READING/WRITING
The Conversation · 08/02/23
Shanahan On Literacy · 08/05/23
STEM
SUSTAINABILITY
New York Times · 08/12/23
“Mr. Peters was broke six years ago, with less than $400 in his checking account after his contracting business slowed down. Then he responded to a help-wanted ad looking for workers to install solar panels, which were becoming more popular in Tulsa. He now employs 61 workers and has $18 million in annual sales. “The environmental benefits are nice,” he said, “but most people are doing this for the financial opportunity.””
New York Times · 08/12/23
“Mr. Leach has since encouraged other farmers to install solar panels. “I’ve had several friends of mine that were, you know, not necessarily trying to save the planet,” he said. “They just wanted to save money.””
New York Times · 08/12/23
“Standing in their way are environmental groups and local residents, all of whom are committed to a clean energy future and worried about the rapid warming of the earth. Still, they want the state to pick a different site for its so-called wind port, citing the tranquillity of Sears Island and its popularity and accessibility as a recreation destination.”
New York Times · 08/09/23
Uncharted Territories · 08/11/23
GENERAL
A.I. Update
TECH/AI
Economist · 04/28/23
“Forget about school essays. Think of the next American presidential race in 2024, and try to imagine the impact of ai tools that can be made to mass-produce political content, fake-news stories and scriptures for new cults… The catch is that it is utterly pointless for us to spend time trying to change the declared opinions of an ai bot, while the ai could hone its messages so precisely that it stands a good chance of influencing us.”
Deep Learning.AI · 08/09/23
“Do large language models understand the world? As a scientist and engineer, I’ve avoided asking whether an AI system “understands” anything. There’s no widely agreed-upon, scientific test for whether a system really understands — as opposed to appearing to understand — just as no such tests exist for consciousness or sentience, as I discussed in an earlier letter. This makes the question of understanding a matter of philosophy rather than science. But with this caveat, I believe that LLMs build sufficiently complex models of the world that I feel comfortable saying that, to some extent, they do understand the world.”
The 74 Million · 08/07/23
TECH/AI: EDUCATION
Learning On Purpose · 08/11/23
“For me, the best way to make sense of AI is to use it. These tools are powerful, but they are imperfect. They have enormous potentials and pitfalls for our world, but the tools available to most of us are accessible and easy to use. They are already doing amazingly sophisticated work in fields like medicine and technology and business, but they also have simple and practical applications in our day-to-day lives. Open up a chatbot like ChatGPT or Bing or Bard or Claude and give a few of the below ideas a try. All of these tools are free to use (sometimes with limits).”
← Previous Issue · Next Issue →