The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #433 (December 10, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Quality over quantity this week:

I wrote this week about redefining academic excellence in the age of AI. So much of the excellence we want for our students is demonstrated through fluency of expression and/or insights into content. What happens when these both become commodities? I reflect on how we might proceed from here, inspired by a project on Zeus for my third grade son and the discovery that ChatGPT can't make cubist images. See the second feature below.

Also this week: the College Board released the revised and official framework for its new AP African American Studies course. After two pilot years, the course is updated with further flexibility for teachers in the final unit. See the press release or explore the full framework in the Curriculum section.

Much more throughout, including a burst of health news for schools, some surprising news from the year in review, and the beginning of some compelling use cases for leveraging AI to support teacher professional development. For the last, head down to the Tech/AI: Education section near the end of the newsletter.

Last, see the inset below for a final invitation to join a session this week on how to incorporate content on the African Diaspora into your teaching.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

AP African American Studies Transitions From Pilot To Official Launch

New York Times · 12/05/23

“The course will launch for credit next fall, and is currently being taught as a pilot program in 700 schools across 40 states… African American studies is an interdisciplinary field, melding history with the study of contemporary politics, culture and law.”

"Redefining Academic Excellence In The Age Of AI”

Sense and Sensation · 12/08/23

“While AI can help students analyze text, identify detail in an image, and structure a work of writing, only the student can apply this understanding to her world. Only the student can integrate new understanding into his school community and personal relationships. Only the student can practice new habits based on new ideas and understanding enabled by AI.”

ARTS

“Best Theater Of 2023”

New York Times · 12/04/23

CREATIVITY

On The Discipline It Takes To Make Things

Austin Kleon · 12/04/23

CURRICULUM

Every Discipline Teaches Its Own Literacy

ASCD · 12/01/23

College Board Press Release On The New AP African American Studies Course

College Board · 12/06/23

HEALTH

“All Indicators For All Respiratory Illnesses Are Increasing”

Your Local Epidemiologist · 12/05/23

“In case we parents didn’t have enough to manage this fall, norovirus—think stomach cramping, intense episodes of vomiting and diarrhea, and occasional fevers—has entered the chat. Levels are higher than this time last year but still far below last year’s peak. Be sure to wash those hands!”

How Are Boys Doing, Mental Health-Wise?

After Babel · 12/06/23

“On any measure related to anxiety or depression, girls have higher absolute rates (the total number of individuals), often two or three times higher, as you see in Figure 1. For suicide it’s the opposite: as a new research brief from AIBM makes clear, the rates for boys are much higher, and their high rate is the deepest sign of a crisis for boys.”

“Schools Increasingly Turn To Online Therapy To Address Student Mental Health”

Campus Safety · 12/07/23

“At least 16 of the 20 largest public school districts in the United States now offer online mental health counseling for their students, according to an analysis by the Associated Press. The contracts for those school districts total more than $70 million. The switch to online therapy is in response to the skyrocketing need for mental health services among students.”

“Teen Suicide Rates Fell In 2022”

EdWeek · 11/29/23

HIGHER ED

Paul LeBlanc To Step Down As President Of SNHU

Chronicle of Higher Education · 12/06/23

HUMANITIES

On “Teaching Social Studies In A Polarized World”

Hechinger Report · 12/07/23

LANGUAGE

Merriam Webster’s Word Of The Year 2023: “Authentic”

Merriam-Webster · 11/27/23

READING/WRITING

Why Content Knowledge Matters When Reading

ASCD · 12/01/23

“Decades ago, studies conducted by reading researchers demonstrated the importance of knowledge to comprehension, as Hugh Catts (2021–2022) has noted. Knowledge, they found, helps readers supply information that authors inevitably leave out—in other words, it helps readers make inferences; take in, analyze, and retain new information; and make predictions. Having knowledge about a topic also increases motivation to read about it.”

STEM

Gender Gaps Remain Large In Most STEM Areas

Gallup · 12/05/23

WORKPLACE

To Support Students, Support The Teachers (Via English Language Learning)

EdWeek · 11/20/23

GENERAL

“20 Things That Happened For The First Time In 2023”

New York Times · 12/05/23

“5. Scientists successfully extract rocks from Earth’s mantle… 7. A man with paralysis walks again using his thoughts… 18. Women vote in a major Vatican meeting.”

A.I. Update

TECH/AI: FEATURED

“375 years of Musings, Warnings, and Arguments Against AI (Part I)”

aiEDU · 12/05/23

“In Part V of Discourse, Descartes makes an aside to explore the difference between humans and automata (machines). Automatons were a curiosity of the time, mechanical creations made to move and mimic people in some way. This led some ambitious and imaginative inventors to claim and strive towards building automatons that would be as capable as humans. This of course led to some conjecture that one day, these automatons might be the equals or even superior to humans. As you might imagine, this idea, dismissed by many as impossible, was also the subject of some philosophical and religious soul searching.”

“Strategy, Not Technology, Is The Key To Winning With GenAI”

Harvard Business Review · 12/06/23

“From a human resources perspective, companies need to strategize on how to retain employees and prepare for higher turnover among workers whose skills complement AI. Standard tools remove how much a company needs to invest in an employee to bring them up to speed. They can increase, however, the resources devoted to hiring and retention.”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

“Improving Your Teaching With An AI Coach”

Edutopia · 12/01/23

“TeachFX’s data reports now identify more than 20 different insights, such as whether teachers are building on what students say, whether they’re asking open-ended questions that push student thinking forward, and how often they’re using academic language in lessons. The technology then analyzes the content of the files that teachers upload, picking out specific words and phrases. Instead of providing only a staid analytics report, the tool also presents its findings conversationally, pointing out strengths and weaknesses the way ChatGPT might.”

The Story Of A Student Falsely Accused Of Using AI

Tech & Learning · 12/03/23

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

On Trust In Society, And How That Plays A Role In AI

Schneier on Security · 12/04/23

“I am going to make several arguments. One, that there are two different kinds of trust—interpersonal trust and social trust—and that we regularly confuse them. Two, that the confusion will increase with artificial intelligence. We will make a fundamental category error. We will think of AIs as friends when they’re really just services. Three, that the corporations controlling AI systems will take advantage of our confusion to take advantage of us. They will not be trustworthy. And four, that it is the role of government to create trust in society. And therefore, it is their role to create an environment for trustworthy AI. And that means regulation. Not regulating AI, but regulating the organizations that control and use AI.”

20 Minute Documentary About The Evolution Of AI Art - Made With AI

Guardian · 12/05/23

TECH/AI: GOVERNMENT AND LAW

“E.U. Agrees On Landmark Artificial Intelligence Rules”

New York Times · 12/08/23

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

Google Launches Gemini — Three Versions Of It

The Verge · 12/06/23

Amanda Bickerstaff Reviews Google Gemini

AI for Education · 12/07/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →