The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #451 (June 23, 2024)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Revisiting the year, creativity, highlights in humanities, generative AI, and more

So many thoughtful pieces this week:

In this week’s features, don’t miss the two lengthy reports Stanford released together, one from a working committee on the Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian student experience and another on Antisemitism and Anti-Israeli bias. While the reports are mostly specific to the Stanford experience, close reading the pairing provides a more nuanced understanding of the layers of issues going on in schools. Both reports include recommendations.

This week’s other feature is a thought provoking exploration into how we define intelligence. The essay focuses on other forms of animal intelligence and backs into today’s AI conversation from there. But mostly, it pushes us to let go of the preciousness with which we hold our own intelligence and examine what different kinds of intelligence enable. It is a perspective-broadening piece.

In other news, this past week’s Tony Awards have led to a series of excellent pieces on the creative process. Also, thoughtful discussion continues on the extent of today’s mental health crisis in kids and what it stems from, and there’s an excellent and video in the Tech section of a nuanced discussion about the promises and perils of AI in education. See also this week’s AI section at the end for much more on AI.

These and much more, including the extraordinary story of Virginia Hislop, who started her degree in education in 1936 and just picked up her diploma in Stanford GSE’s graduation ceremony last week at age 105. Amazing.

Enjoy!

Peter

PS. I have noticed that with AI crowding the news cycle, stories on teacher practice are less prevalent. I am working on some projects laser focused on practice and connecting teachers around practice, and I would like to hear from you, either as teachers or administrators or 3rd party organizations that are supporting teacher practice. If you’re open to speaking with me about your focus on teacher practice, please schedule a 20 minute meeting with me at this link. I would love to speak with you. Thank you!

Virginia Hislop at her graduation, age 105. See the article in “Other” below. (photo: Charles Russo)
Virginia Hislop at her graduation, age 105. See the article in “Other” below. (photo: Charles Russo)

FEATURED

We Need To Rethink What Intelligence Is

Aeon · 06/17/24

“Humanity’s relationship to AI is characterised by similar cycles of underestimation and surprise, followed by exploration, understanding and explanation, and a subsequent downgrading of our belief that intelligence is currently at play… This is sometimes called the ‘AI effect’, explained by the computer scientist Larry Tesler as our tendency to believe that ‘Intelligence is whatever machines haven’t done yet.’ Now that it is possible for machines to beat human chess grandmasters, the game is no longer widely seen as a marker of ‘true’ intelligence… Eventually, instead of talking about how machines, animal collectives, or individual birds and bugs exhibit intelligence, we should be better prepared to investigate how they evolved or iterated those actions in their own evolutionary spaces, unshackled from human-shaped standards… A planet full of problem-solving life exists apart from humans, and none of it is obligated to fit neatly into our subjective, self-serving mindset. We need to avoid the real risk that we will miss animal or machine (or plant, fungal, bacterial, or even extraterrestrial) ways of succeeding just because they are fundamentally alien to our conceptual toolkit.

“Two Reports Released On Communities Significantly Impacted by Events On Oct 7.”

Stanford · 06/20/24

“Two separate committees – the Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian Communities Committee and the Subcommittee on Antisemitism and Anti-Israeli Bias – have each released reports from their seven-month reviews of what people in their communities have experienced before and after the events of Oct. 7, 2023.”

ADMISSIONS

"Meet The Internet’s ‘Admissions Dad’” Prashant Sehgal

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 06/18/24

“He’s a moderator for three college-admissions forums on Reddit, including one of Reddit’s largest communities about the topic, called ApplyingToCollege, which has 1.1 million users.”

ARTS

“Did Auguste Rodin Steal From Camille Claudel?”

Hyperallergic · 06/17/24

CHARACTER

“Trolley Problem Variations For Dads” [Humor]

McSweeney’s · 06/14/24

“After you explain the situation to him, your father approaches the conductor and begins asking questions about what kind of engine he’s got in this thing.”

“A Few Lessons From Roger Federer’s Dartmouth Commencement Speech”

Kottke · 06/20/24

“In tennis, perfection is impossible… In the 1,526 singles matches I played in my career, I won almost 80% of those matches… Now, I have a question for all of you… what percentage of the POINTS do you think I won in those matches? Only 54%.”

On Idleness: Doing Nothing Has Never Been More Important

The Walrus · 06/13/24

CREATIVITY

How Did David Adjmi Write Stereophonic, The Most Tony Nominated Play Ever?

Broadway News · 05/24/24

“Adjmi writes on instinct. So much so that he didn’t initially write “Stereophonic”’s dialogue on a page; he dictated it to an assistant. “I would just start talking, and then I would have her transcribe everything I said, and then she would read it back to me and I’d say, ‘Cut that.’ ‘Put that line over there.’ ‘Now read it again.’ ‘Now add interruptions here, here and here.’ ‘Okay, now I’ll read it with you,’” he recalled. “I was just talking off the top of my head.” Which accounts for the dialogue’s uncanny naturalism. Characters talk on top of one another. They start one conversation and it turns into another entirely. They think out loud. Because that’s what Adjmi was doing.”

How Did Branden Jacobs-Jenkins Write His Tony Award Winning Play “Appropriate”?

Broadway News · 06/11/24

“Because the “family drama” feels deeply American, Jacobs-Jenkins wanted to write his own. But he was stuck. So he reread every play he could think of that fit the genre — those by Eugene O’Neill, Arthur Miller, Tennessee Williams, Horton Foote, Lorraine Hansberry, August Wilson, Sam Shepard — and decided to “steal one thing from every play that I really liked, and I typed up pieces of the plays, and I put them in one big Word document, and I would just work at that thing and call that my negative first draft,” Jacobs-Jenkins said. “In some ways, I tried to imbue all the energy of these plays into this one.””

What Can We Learn From The Recent PISA Results On Creativity?

EdWeek · 06/18/24

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

Interview With Nikole Hannah-Jones About The 1619 Project

Literary Hub · 06/19/24

HEALTH

“By Some Measures, Students’ Well-Bring Has Been Stable For A Decade”

EdWeek · 06/14/24

“The report by Challenge Success, a nonprofit affiliated with Stanford University’s graduate school of education, found a significant number of students do struggle with getting adequate sleep, high levels of stress, and academic worry. But it also found relatively stable trends over time regarding students’ sense of belonging and engagement in school.”

“Yes, Everyone Really Is Sick A Lot More Often After COVID”

Yahoo · 06/16/24

How Has Mental Health Changed Across Demographic Groups Since 2010?

After Babel · 06/20/24

HIGHER ED

How Is Hampshire College Doing, Five Years Later?

Higher Ed Dive · 06/20/24

HUMANITIES

“Social Media’s Favorite English Teacher”

Edutopia · 06/14/24

“The Case For Not Sanitizing Fairy Tales”

Plough · 06/17/24

What Is The Next Industrial Revolution?

The Mind File · 06/20/24

Behold The Renovated Folger Library

New York Times · 06/21/24

LEADERSHIP

What Is A Crisis: A Philosophical And Etymological Viewpoint

Aeon · 06/20/24

How Do You Equitably Compensate Teachers?

Hechinger Report · 06/20/24

PEDAGOGY

Play Is Essential, Especially In Crisis Contexts

Brookings · 06/20/24

“Crisis contexts, whether due to conflict, economic or political upheaval, climate change or natural hazards, impact young children in myriad ways. They can displace children from their homes, cut off access to education, health, nutritious food, and other services, and impact them psychologically and emotionally. Play in these contexts becomes even more important as it enables young children to repair the fractures of their protective environment, reestablish relationships and routines, decrease stress, and pave the way for learning to continue. That learning goes beyond academic skills of reading, writing, and math. Learning through play enables children to practice and develop critical breadth of skills such as empathy, collaboration, problem-solving, negotiation, and more that they need to thrive and contribute positively to the world.”

READING/WRITING

“What About Tracing And Other Multi-Sensory Teaching Approaches?”

Shanahan On Literacy · 06/22/24

SOCIAL MEDIA

“Surgeon General: Why I’m Calling For A Warning Label On Social Media Platforms”

New York Times · 06/17/24

In Praise Of The Surgeon General’s Call For A Warning On Social Media

After Babel · 06/18/24

STEM

Sudoku Player Analyzes 100 Easy NYT Sodoku Puzzles

Vivek Rao · 06/01/24

“The Math Kids Most Want To Learn”

Dan Meyer · 06/19/24

The Earth’s Inner Core Is Slowing Down. It’s Called “Backtracking”

Live Science · 06/19/24

TECH

Messy Handwriting: It’s Not Tech’s Fault, It’s Been Around Forever

The Conversation · 06/09/24

“In fact, Shakespeare’s Hamlet says just that: “I once did hold it, as our statists do, A baseness to write fair, and labored much How to forget that learning” That is, elegant handwriting was a tell-tale skill of the upwardly mobile, not those who were born into power and privilege. Writing carelessly could be a way of asserting one’s social or political clout by forcing others less privileged to struggle to decipher what one had written.”

“What 40 Million Messages Tell Us About Parent-Teacher Communication”

EdSurge · 06/20/24

“The results found that 44 percent of the messages were around logistics.. Only 8 percent of messages were about academics, followed by homework at 5 percent.”

“It’s Time To Retire The Term “User””

MIT Technology Review · 04/19/24

“Parents Are key When it Comes To Limiting Screen Time For Kids”

NPR · 06/08/24

Esports At One School: From 10 Students To 400 In Four Years

CBS12 · 06/11/24

EdTech Is Good; EdTech Is Bad - An Excellent “Debate” On The Topic [Video]

GSV · 06/13/24

The Short, Happy Life Of The CD-ROM

Fast Company · 06/17/24

“School Cellphone Bans Gain Steam”

EdWeek · 06/19/24

WORKPLACE

“Hybrid Work Has Changed Meetings Forever”

Harvard Business Review · 06/17/24

“For this analysis, we evaluated more than 40 million meetings from 11 organizations, spanning more than 450,000 unique employees… Both camera enablement and no-participation rates show strong correlations with retention. Employees who would leave their organization within one year of the sample period (attrition group) enabled their cameras in 18.4% of small group meetings, compared to 32.5% for those who stayed (retention group).”

GENERAL

“He Memorized The World With Google Maps. Now He’s Exploring It.”

New York Times · 06/19/24

“After a while, his memory grew planetary. When you see cabbage-like plants thriving along the sides of a Russian country road, he learned, you’re most likely looking at Sakhalin Island. On a bridge lined with pea-green pavement? You’re above a river in Indonesia’s Central Kalimantan province. If your vista, but for the sweep of golden grasslands, screams South Africa, you’ll be in Eswatini.”

105-Year-Old Collects Her Masters Degree 80 Years Later

Stanford · 06/16/24

"Managing The Time To Build Your Side Hustle”

Harvard Business Review · 06/17/24

The Return Of Microschools

New York Times · 06/17/24

“The Next Popular Character To Enter The Public Domain, Visualized”

Digg · 06/18/24


A.I. Update

A year for developing nuance

Earlier in the year, I cited a post by EdTech Insiders that characterized this past year as a Cambrian Explosion of AI technology. Indeed, the landscape has been flooded with companies and products and hype. This current year, therefore, was naturally going to become the Darwinian Selection of which technologies and companies would last. And this would happen because this would be the year when schools and other contexts began to determine where actual value could be found with the new technology, and what was just hype.

This week’s posts prove this out. They demonstrate a growing understanding of the implications of generative AI and how we can actually navigate and engage with it in schools. In this issue, find reflections on the importance of friction in learning (as opposed to ease with AI), on AI in the writing process, on AI and grading, and one of my favorites: Maha Bali’s musings on how AI might affect our imagination. See general pieces, too, on the teacherpreneur: the special founders who know exactly how AI might be useful, because they see ways that AI can solve problems they have in front of them.

There is so much still to learn in this moment of extraordinary opportunity.

Enjoy!

Peter

Several key insights from last week’s post from FlexOS. Find last week’s posts at www.educatorsnotebook.com
Several key insights from last week’s post from FlexOS. Find last week’s posts at www.educatorsnotebook.com

TECH/AI: FEATURED

"AI Plagiarism Considerations… When Students Use AI”

Lance Eaton · 06/20/24

“In this one, I’m going to provide some guidance and insights about how faculty might engage with students once they suspect that a student might have inappropriately used generative AI.”

“How Will Our Imagination Be Affected By AI? Musings.”

Maha Bali · 06/22/24

“Human creativity augmented with AI would only be beneficial, IMHO, if the weight of human judgment before and after AI use is high. In the same way it’s important to make a mental calculation of something before you put it into the calculator so that you know roughly what should come out, I think with AI we need to constantly do this, not just to preserve our imagination, but to also preserve our criticality and awareness of epistemic bias.”

TECH/AI

Getting Expert Outcomes From GenAI Requires Experts, For Now

One Useful Thing · 06/20/24

“If making current AI systems work better is about expert guidance, then we need experts to share what they learn, or people will use AI in ways that don’t draw on latent expertise. For every student using our tutor prompt, tens of thousands of students are just asking the AI to explain something “like I am 10 years old.” For every carefully build job description, thousands of people are just using LLMs and getting indifferent results. Success is going to come from getting experts to use these systems and share what they learn.”

“The Rise Of The Teacherpreneur In The Age Of AI”

EdTechInsiders · 06/18/24

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

An Excellent Reflection On AI And The Writing Process

Unmaking the Grade · 06/14/24

“In order for students to make informed choices about AI, they have to be knowledgeable not only about AI tools themselves but also about their own writing processes. Unfortunately, most students enter my class without a well-defined, well-developed, or personalized process, much less a deep awareness of that process. They have to cultivate their own process and a reflective stance on that process at the same time that they’re trying to figure out how AI might affect their growth as writers. This strikes me as an exceedingly difficult task.”

A Course For Examining The Implications Of Writing With AI

Writing Commons · 12/01/23

More Reflections On The Importance Of Friction In Learning

Pandora’s Bot · 05/28/24

"How Learning Designers Are Using AI For Analysis”

Dr Philippa Hardman · 06/14/24

Digital Promise Deepens Their AI Literacy Framework

Digital Promise · 06/15/24

“Teens Are Looking To AI For Information And Answers”

Hechinger Report · 06/17/24

Should You Use AI For Grading? Some Say No.

Leon Furze · 06/20/24

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

A Quick Refresher On AI And Equity For K-12 Schools

EdWeek · 06/20/24

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →