The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #457 (August 13, 2024)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Articles and Announcement

This week, I am so happy to share the arrival of AthenaLab.io.

Many of you may have followed the evolution and growth of Athena over the years. Now, it is reborn as Athena Lab, and we are bringing it from a side project to scale. Why? Teachers are still isolated. Administrators want to support teacher growth. Both say they are hungry for better, more effective ways to connect teachers around resources. Both say that this is exactly what Athena Lab does for them.

Some updates:

* Refreshed website: We’ve streamlined and refreshed our new home at AthenaLab.io.
* AI and Teaching & Learning: We have partnered with the Middle States Association to support the RAIL endorsement for artificial intelligence, enabling teachers across participating schools to collaborate, share resources, and provide feedback for each other on how they are integrating AI into their teaching and learning.
* Learning about the African Diaspora: We continue to deepen our relationship with the African Diaspora Consortium, which is growing their AP seminar course materials (now in over 100 schools) and expanding into both higher education and K-8 settings.
* As always, find resources: the first day of class: Here are over 100 ways to engage students on day one. One of my favorites: “Identify tensions in current events to set a basis for understanding historical tensions.” (Anything happening in current events these days…?). Want to train students for Harkness discussions? Here are practical exercises to build Harkness skills. Find these and more.
I’d love to keep learning from you about your experiences and needs. Are you a school leader looking to connect teachers around practice to improve teaching and learning? Are you a teacher looking to expand your network of colleagues, or to find new approaches to what you teach? I’d like to hear about it. Please don’t hesitate to sign up for a 20 minute call.

---

So many other good things in this week’s issue, too.

In the features, find posts on student sleep habits and on concrete data about student wellness. The Gallup data is super helpful for seeing kids’ emotional lives in context.

Also, for joyful, free, content-based discussion groups on great texts, check out the Catherine Project. Registration for their next round of reading groups is open this week only. I wrote about the Catherine Project here. See the humanities section for more. Registration closes this Friday, 8/16.

Also in the news this week: religion in schools. Oklahoma and Louisiana, where superintendents have required teaching the Bible and posting the Ten Commandments, have prompted discussions both within their states and across the country about the role of religion in schools. See the curriculum section for more.

See also the pedagogy section for more first day activities (see above), active learning approaches, supporting executive function, and more.

All these and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

“The Sleep Crisis Among Students”

Challenge Success · 07/29/24

“The 2024 Student Voice Report presents a comprehensive analysis of high school students’ emotional and physical health, sense of connection and belonging in school, and engagement with learning, based on data collected from over 375,000 students from 2010 to 2023.  On average, high school students report receiving only 6.6 hours of sleep per night, far below the recommended 8-10 hours for their age group. This sleep deficit is not just a minor inconvenience—it has profound implications for students’ health, well-being, and academic performance.”

Data On The Emotional Lives Of Adolescents (And Their Parents)

Gallup · 07/30/24

“The most recent survey, which is part of a larger body of research on Gen Z by the Walton Family Foundation and Gallup, was conducted online March 13-20, 2024, with 1,675 10- to 18-year-old youth and one of their parents or guardians via the probability-based Gallup Panel. It finds that, rather than being completely positive or completely negative, the emotional lives of preteens and teenagers are complex. Nearly all of these children (94%) say they felt happiness a lot of the prior day; however, 45% also felt stressed, 38% anxious, and 23% sad.”

ASSESSMENT

Information From The College Board On Digital AP Testing

College Board · 07/25/24

CHARACTER

“Ten Meter Tower” - NYT Documentary About Jumping From A High Dive

New York Times · 01/30/17

“Our objective in making this film was something of a psychology experiment: We sought to capture people facing a difficult situation, to make a portrait of humans in doubt. We’ve all seen actors playing doubt in fiction films, but we have few true images of the feeling in documentaries. To make them, we decided to put people in a situation powerful enough not to need any classic narrative framework. A high dive seemed like the perfect scenario.”

“5 Tips For Writing Meaningful Thank-You Notes”

Harvard Business Review · 08/08/24

“Take time to reflect; thank those who are often forgotten; be specific; make it matter; and it’s never too late.”

“19 Ways To Help Elementary Students Self-Regulate”

Edutopia · 08/07/24

CREATIVITY

Why Constraints Drive Creativity (Via Ryan Reynolds And Deadpool)

Inc. · 07/26/24

CURRICULUM

How The Ten Commandments Requirement In Louisiana Is Going

EdWeek · 08/07/24

“Public schools can meet the requirements of a new Louisiana law that calls for a Ten Commandments poster in every classroom without violating students’ constitutional rights, Attorney General Liz Murrill argued. The law, signed June 19, has already been challenged in federal court. But supporters of such displays are emboldened by recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions they see as cracking open the door to more religious displays and texts in schools.”

What Is The Right Way To Teach Religion In Schools?

EdWeek · 08/08/24

“Will your students have the opportunity to be exposed to other religious texts such as the Torah, the Quran, the Bhagavad Gita, or the Tripitaka (just to name a few) to compare and contrast their historical and present impact on societies around the world? …Will your policies also engage students in discussions of why humans are or are not religious at all? Will you make all students, even the nonreligious ones, feel welcome to learn in your schools?”

Rather Teaching Than Religion, Schools Should Teach Today’s Moral Quandaries

Hechinger Report · 07/30/24

Oklahoma Teachers And Leaders Continue To Navigate The Bible Requirement

Oklahoman · 08/07/24

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

Four Tips For Talking About Race In The Classroom

Higher Ed Dive · 08/05/24

HIGHER ED

More Non-College Paths To Jobs Emerge

Hechinger Report · 07/31/24

HISTORY OF EDUCATION

“Whatever Happened To The Coalition Of Essential Schools?”

Larry Cuban · 08/09/24

“It is gone. What began as Ted Sizer’s ground-breaking effort to reform U.S.’s 25,000 high schools in 1984 reached 1000-plus schools by 1997, the year Sizer retired from CES. By 2017, however, CES had closed operations with less than 100 affiliated schools. Is this another story of a reform birthed in one educational crisis and dying during a later one? Or is it a story of a national program centered around one smart, engaging, and knowledgeable high school reformer who, over time, built an organization that lost energy after the founder left? Or is it a time-tested story of a reform that succeeded by spreading its gospel far and wide in policies, programs, and places?”

HUMANITIES

“Studying Middles Eastern History Through Graphic Novels”

Stanford · 07/26/24

Efforts Expand To Increase Information Literacy In Youth Ahead Of Election

74 Million · 07/31/24

LEADERSHIP

PACE Layers: Institutional Change Requires Coordination Of Multiple Layers

Middle States Association · 07/01/24

“If accreditation serves as the concept model for the endorsement-as-credential, then Stewart Brand’s “pace layering” model is the concept model for the endorsement-as-implementation framework. Brand’s pace layering model reflects how complex, adaptive systems change over time. The layer at the bottom changes the slowest, with each layer above changing more quickly.”

A Collection Of Articles About Effective Faculty Meetings

EdWeek · 08/01/24

“Are You A Micromanager Or Too Hands Off?”

Harvard Business Review · 08/02/24

Examples Of CEO-Level Email Communication Between Leaders

Inc. · 08/05/24

LEARNING SCIENCE

A Definition Of Learning

Martin Skelton · 06/24/24

“Learning, getting better, happens successfully when our brains, through repeated experiences, engage in a good struggle to a) create or extend an existing neuronal chain b) make a neuronal constellation more complex or c) hardwire an existing chain so that it fires automatically and becomes sticky. When this happens we acquire knowledge, develop our skills and deepen our understandings in different ways and over different periods of time.”

7-38-55: Albert Mehrabian And How We Convey Meaning Through Words, Face, And Tone

Inc. · 03/29/24

PD

“On Reading Plato In The Age Of AI”

Sense and Sensation · 06/26/24

“One of this past year’s great joys was participating in a reading group on Socratic Dialogues with The Catherine Project.  Every Tuesday night for 3-4 months I joined a zoom call with more than a dozen strangers from around the world to talk about Plato’s writing for 90 minutes.  It was free and it was excellent.  As an educator, I had found references to Socrates unavoidable — the Socratic method, the maxim “Know thyself,” the pursuit of a “good life” — but I had never encountered Socrates on my own, and I felt I should do something about it. I had encountered the Catherine Project through a reader of the newsletter and I thought to try it out… What a joy. In my group were 18-20 individuals from all walks of life. They spanned from retirees to recent college graduates. They came from across the Americas, Australia, and Europe. They were women and men. They were like our classes: full of diverse personalities, skeptical and enthusiastic, quiet and verbose, full of questions and full of answers.”

Great PD: Free Reading Groups On Great Texts [Deadline Aug 16]

Catherine Project · 08/01/24

“We offer a variety of courses focused on particular great books, ancient languages, and other related subjects. These courses offer opportunities to focus one’s learning in a welcoming intellectual community. Our courses are open to adults 16 years or older from all educational backgrounds and walks of life. Most courses meet weekly for between 1-2 hours.”

PEDAGOGY

What To Do In Social Studies/History On Day One?

History Tech · 08/07/24

“You’ll have tons of time to assess students’ strengths and weaknesses. You have months to discuss high stakes testing and standards. You’ll spend weeks probing the textbook. So the first few days of school should be dedicated to rapport-building and to joy. Your goal should be that students go home that night and tell their parents: “I’m going to love this class!”

Dan Meyer Finishes His Series On How To Teach Kids Who Struggle

Dan Meyer · 07/31/24

A Reminder Of Some Basic Active Learning Techniques

Higher Ed Praxis · 08/01/24

On Building Routines To Support Executive Function

Cult of Pedagogy · 08/04/24

“6 Ideas To Perk Up Your First Day Of Class”

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 08/05/24

What Are Your Goals For The First Day Of Class?

Dan Meyer · 08/07/24

READING/WRITING

“100 Of The Greatest Posters Of Celebrities Urging You To Read”

Literary Hub · 07/18/24

“In Which James Folta Bravely Attempts to Rank the Iconic ALA Series”

Meta-Analysis Of How EdTech Helps Kids Learn To Read

Stanford · 08/05/24

“For the meta-analysis, the researchers drew on 119 studies published between 2010 and 2023 to examine the use of various digital interventions in kindergarten through fifth grade, including computer programs, e-books, online games, and videos… Their analysis found positive effects on elementary school students’ reading skills overall, indicating that generally, investing in educational technology to support literacy is warranted. But when the researchers isolated particular learning outcomes to measure effectiveness, they found wide variability, suggesting that the effectiveness of a particular edtech product can depend on different factors, including features of the tool and characteristics of the users.”

Presidential Speechwriter Describes Being Told To Cut 15% Of Speech

LinkedIn · 08/12/24

““This is a good six-page speech,” he said. I was thrilled. He liked it! And then he added: “It would be a great five-page speech.” I chuckled. I thought he was teasing me. He wasn’t. “See if you can shave a page off,” he said, handing me the speech and walking back to his cabin. I looked down at the pages, assuming he’d offered some suggestions on what to cut. He hadn’t.

SAFETY

“Academic Special Forces” - Vanderbilt Builds A Cybersecurity Initiative

Vanderbilt · 08/06/24

“As part of a new national security institute, Professor Holly Tucker leads students in a novel research program to prevent cybersecurity attacks.”

Can Active Shooter Drills Prepare Without Traumatizing?

EdWeek · 07/31/24

SOCIAL MEDIA

YouTube Is The Most Dominant Streaming Service

New Consumer · 08/02/24

STEM

“Swish: Teaching Fractions On The Basketball Court”

K12 Dive · 07/31/24

Simone Biles Double Back Layout Appears To Defy Gravity, Teaches Center Of Gravity

Facebook · 08/02/24

SUSTAINABILITY

Reminder: Heat Affects Learning

Hechinger Report · 07/29/24

“The effect extreme heat is having on schools and childcare is starting to get the attention of policymakers and researchers. Last week, the Center for American Progress, a left-leaning think tank, published a report on the issue. In April, so did the Federation of American Scientists a nonprofit policy organization.”

“How Colleges Can Become Living Labs For Combating Climate Change”

Hechinger Report · 07/30/24

“The project would require $43,613 in startup money. It would be profitable within roughly five years, the students said. And over 50 years, it would save the university $787,130 in energy costs.”

“The Hidden Costs Of Climate Change On The Workforce”

Harvard Business Review · 07/29/24

“How Does Your State Make Electricity?” [Revisited]

New York Times · 08/02/24

TECH

15 Top Tech Trends

McKinsey · 07/16/24

“Senate Passes Bipartisan Bills To Protect Children, Teens Online”

K12 Dive · 07/31/24

WORKPLACE

“Rural Schools Are Fighting For Their Existence”

EdWeek · 07/29/24


A.I. Update

AI Adoption continues growing, AI Companionship grows, too

Much to learn from this week.

Most significant, I think, is the growing trend of AI companionship. In one of this week’s features, Marc Watkins describes this as “synthetic relationships.” He is right that human beings need authentic relationships, but also that there may be a space for AI-human connection to support specific needs. This will be a very complex puzzle for us as a society in the years ahead. See the Uses and Applications section for one such effort, called “Friend,” which I think misses the mark but is a sign of what is to come.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

Adoption of ChatGPT across Occupations (see Uses and Applications for more)
Adoption of ChatGPT across Occupations (see Uses and Applications for more)

TECH/AI: FEATURED

We Are In An Age Of Synthetic Relationships. They’re Growing.

Marc Watkins · 08/02/24

“It is increasingly looking like generative AI won’t become intelligent to achieve true AGI, but human beings will still put their trust into these black box systems and may one day be willing to cede autonomy and critical decision-making to an algorithm. To those who scoff at this, and I imagine there are many, know that I was very much among your ranks. Then I started thinking about how much of my life is already mitigated by algorithms and machine learning. How many of us are lost without GPS guiding us, mobile food orders, and all things digital commerce, or our wearable smart devices informing us of our diets, heart rates, and even when a female is ovulating?”

What Students Wants From AI: Survey of 3,500+ College Students

Digital Education Council · 08/07/24

“86% of students globally are regularly using AI in their studies, with 54% of them using AI on a weekly basis… Despite their high rates of AI usage, 1 in 2 students do not feel AI ready.”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

Researchers Submit 100% AI Generated Writing For University Courses

PLOS One · 06/26/24

“We found that 94% of our AI submissions were undetected. The grades awarded to our AI submissions were on average half a grade boundary higher than that achieved by real students. Across modules there was an 83.4% chance that the AI submissions on a module would outperform a random selection of the same number of real student submissions.”

A Case For Not Using AI For Writing Until After The First Draft

Marc Watkins · 08/09/24

“The first draft is the child's draft, where you let it all pour out and then let it romp all over the place, knowing that no one is going to see it and that you can shape it later. You just let this childlike part of you channel whatever voices and visions come through and onto the page. Having AI generate a draft for you might not give you the same experience because an AI-generated draft might be something’s child’s draft, but not your own. The creative risks aren’t the same. Yes, you get a fast start from going to a blank page to a rough draft but having a machine do that for you feels like leaping from the crowd in front of the Boston Marathon and sprinting the last hundred yards ahead of everyone else.”

A Collection Of State Guidance On AI

AI for Education · 08/01/24

Should Educators Disclose When They Use AI?

EdSurge · 08/01/24

“How Close Is AI To Replacing Instructional Designers?” - A Small Test

Dr Philippa Hardman · 08/08/24

A Collection Of Articles About AI In Schools

Learning on Purpose · 08/08/24

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

AI Transcription Tool Catches, Shares Researchers Insulting Interviewee After Call

Inside Higher Ed · 08/06/24

“After the Zoom interview ended, he received an email from Otter, a popular transcription program that uses AI to convert audio to text, sharing a both a transcript and the original audio. The recording had continued after Hill left the Zoom interview, capturing the researchers’ thoughts, Hill said.”

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

"Why Agents Are The Next Frontier Of Generative AI”

McKinsey · 07/24/24

“AI Achieves Silver Medal Standard Solving International Math Olympiad”

Google · 07/25/24

What’s Next After LLMs?

Gary Marcus · 07/28/24

TECH/AI: USES AND APPLICATIONS

Case Study: “Can AI Make A Data-Driven, Visual Story?”

Pudding · 07/01/24

“It’s sort of like comparing a woodworking artisan’s table to one from IKEA. The artisans invest immense time and effort into their high-quality pieces, while IKEA produces things quickly and cheaply, and most people probably can’t tell the difference (or don’t care). Which is kind of sad for us artisans. With AI, we can expect a rise in superficially appealing but low-quality content. But that doesn’t mean there’s no place for craftsmanship. We still find meaning in the bespoke, at doing all the little things right, and in creating things that feel like they have a real person at the other end of it. And we can only hope that others do too.”

Google Achieves Human Level Competitive Robot Table Tennis

Google · 08/01/24

“Achieving human-level speed and performance on real world tasks is a north star for the robotics research community. This work takes a step towards that goal and presents the first learned robot agent that reaches amateur human-level performance in competitive table tennis. Table tennis is a physically demanding sport which requires human players to undergo years of training to achieve an advanced level of proficiency.”

AI Adoption By Work Industry - Survey of 100,000 Workers

UChicago · 06/20/24

“Friend” - An AI Powered Necklace That Texts You When You’re Lonely

CNET · 07/30/24

“The Evolving Safety And Policy Challenges Of Self-Driving Cars”

Brookings · 07/31/24

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →