The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #408 (February 26, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Two weeks with much to think about!

The alarm around ChatGPT is fading, and now two things are happening: both the limits and the more nuanced opportunities are becoming more clear. See not only the featured article this week, but also posts in tech, admissions, reading/writing, and more. Especially surprising is the first article in the tech section in which a writer from the NYT describes an alarming conversation with Microsoft's instance of the chatbot.

For a step back into the deeply human part of our work, peruse the feature article on the purposes of education. It's an interesting and grounding take on whether we are preparing students for life after school or educating for the intrinsic value of learning (or both).

A few other highlights: science writer Annie Murphy Paul is back with what promises to be a series of compelling research posts on creativity, there's a pairing of posts on professional use of TikTok, find some excellent STEM and humanities pieces and much, much more this week. This is longest Educator's Notebook in the near decade of sharing it.

Enjoy!

FEATURED

Should School Breathe Life Into Students Or Equip Them For The Future?

The Point · 02/13/23

“The issue with the will to equip, then, is not the desire to prepare students for the future, but the impoverishment of our educational imagination that so often accompanies it. In the grips of the equipage mentality, we forget, first, that the educational experiences of young people can carry their value in themselves and not only for the sake of something else outside of them, to be experienced later in life. Moreover, we tend to equate educational “success” with future material pleasures, won through the enjoyment of consumer goods, and afforded by maximally lucrative and socially respected occupations. These two tendencies are closely related: we have a circumscribed view of personal success in part because we overlook the kinds of goods that are already available to young people in the classroom.”

ChatGPT Is An Example Machine For Teachers. This Is Excellent.

Cult of Pedagogy · 02/19/23

“Our goal was to help students learn the underlying principles of kinetic and potential energy. We used ChatGPT to generate a range of different examples of kinetic and potential energy. Kids could sort these examples into categories and then explain their choices. In the screenshots below, the text next to the yellow icon is our prompt, and the text next to the green icon is ChatGPT’s response.”

ADMISSIONS

Some Initial Thoughts On How A.I. Could Support Admissions

Student Doctor Network · 02/12/23

ADOLESCENCE

Sleep, School, And Suicide: A Stunning Correlation And Visualization

Scientific American · 02/01/23

“Data published by the CDC and analyzed by emergency pediatric psychiatrist Tyler Black show a clear pattern: children die by suicide at much higher rates on school days than they do on weekends or during summer months… Like many of his peers in pediatric medicine, he calls for later school start times, among other measures, to help improve kids’ mental health.”

What Does It Mean That Christian Revivals Are Growing Among The Young?

New York Times · 02/23/23

“The unplanned event has strained the campus and kept the little chapel filled at all hours, prompting administrators to wind down the spectacle and disruption. Beginning Friday, the school said, there will be no more public events. Students said they were ready to return to their normal campus rhythms. Nascent revivals are now breaking out at other college campuses, including at Lee University in Tennessee and Cedarville University in Ohio, though it remains to be seen if they will sustain the same fervor seen in Asbury.”

CHARACTER

“Stop Adopting Other People’s Anxiety”

Dear Design Student · 09/23/15

Movement As Conflict Resolution

Berkeley · 02/08/23

Stanford On Love: The Science, Sociology, Chemistry, And More

Stanford · 02/13/23

“Excellencism” - An Alternative To Perfectionism

Annie Murphy Paul · 02/22/23

CREATIVITY

Certainty, Competence, And What Makes Creativity

Annie Murphy Paul · 02/15/23

Some Myths About Creativity

Annie Murphy Paul · 02/16/23

Task Switching Promotes Creativity

Annie Murphy Paul · 02/17/23

Memory And Imagination Draw On The Same Mental Capacities

Annie Murphy Paul · 02/23/23

CURRICULUM

The Carnegie Foundation Wants To Ditch The Carnegie Unit. Why?

EdWeek · 12/08/22

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

"Is It Possible To Wear Clothes From Other Cultures Without Appropriation?”

New York Times · 02/13/23

“If Racial Identity Can Be Fluid, Who Changes Their Race?”

Psyche · 02/14/23

The Experience Of Two Teachers Piloting AP African American Studies

EdWeek · 02/16/23

“In Defense Of J.K. Rowling”

New York Times · 02/16/23

How Some UK Schools Are Reckoning With Andrew Tate And Growing Misogyny

New York Times · 02/19/23

“New Higher Ed Data By Race And Ethnicity”

Hechinger Report · 02/20/23

“The Point Of Education Is Not To Reduce Harm”

Chronicle of Higher Education · 02/23/23

On Roald Dahl, And A Brief History Of Sensitivity Edits In Children’s Lit

The Conversation · 02/23/23

HIGHER ED

Northeastern (Boston) Acquired Mills (SF). How’s It Going So Far?

Boston · 02/13/23

Is College Necessary? Trades Provide Another Path

Hechinger Report · 02/14/23

HUMANITIES

“The Books That Made The European Enlightenment”

The Critic · 02/01/23

Henry Louis Gates Jr. On Teaching African American History

New York Times · 02/17/23

LANGUAGE

Spoken Latin Is Making A Comeback

Smithsonian · 02/14/23

LEADERSHIP

Hold Your Team Accountable With Compassion, Not Fear

Harvard Business Review · 02/13/23

Good Team Questions: “What Are You Stuck On?”

Harvard Business Review · 02/14/23

What The Most Productive Companies Do Differently

Harvard Business Review · 02/16/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

Q&A With Daniel Willingham On Science-Backed Study Habits

Edutopia · 02/10/23

PD

Team Teaching As Teacher Retention And Empowerment Tool

Getting Smart · 02/14/23

PEDAGOGY

On Building A Weekly Class Routine

Edutopia · 02/14/23

Does Flipped Learning Work? A Metaanalysis

EdSurge · 02/16/23

“15 Ways To Teach And Learn With Sticky Notes”

Middle Web · 02/20/23

Retakes And Revisions As Leading Tools For Motivating Student Excellence

EdWeek · 02/23/23

Should We Have Homework?

Vox · 02/23/23

READING/WRITING

Academe Wrestles With ChatGPT Guidelines For Faculty

Chronicle of Higher Education · 02/22/23

“For example, the editors of Science have decided that authors should not use text generated by ChatGPT in a submitted manuscript. Fair enough. But can authors use ChatGPT to generate an early outline for a manuscript? …What feels most different about ChatGPT compared to other assistive technologies is the possible reduction of intellectual labor. For most professors, writing — even bad first drafts or outlines — requires our labor (and sometimes strain) to develop an original thought. If the goal is to write a paper that introduces boundary-breaking new ideas, AI tools might reduce some of the intellectual effort needed to make that happen.”

Kristof: A Summary On What We Know About Teaching Reading

New York Times · 02/11/23

We All Have Three Voices: Thinking, Speaking, Writing

Austin Kleon · 02/15/23

Should We Still Teach Writing In An Age Of Generative A.I.?

Larry Cuban · 02/18/23

“A Blog Post Is A Search Query To Find Your People”

Austin Kleon · 02/19/23

Teacher Makes Videos Annotating And Close Reading Macbeth

Julian Girdham · 02/20/23

SAFETY

The 10th Campus Safety Conference Is In July

Campus Safety · 02/14/23

SOCIAL MEDIA

BookTok, Where Authors And Readers Meet On TikTok

Literary Hub · 02/13/23

TeacherTok, Where Teachers Go On TikTok

EdWeek · 02/14/23

STEM

Geometry Puzzle: How Many Patterns Of Rectangles Fit In A Square?

New York Times · 02/07/23

Where The Elements Came From

Kottke · 02/08/23

Da Vinci Was Figuring Out Gravitational Constants Centuries Before Newton

New York Times · 02/17/23

A Math-English Collaborative Project: Word Field Notes (Via NYT)

New York Times · 02/22/23

SUSTAINABILITY

Heat Pumps: A Rapidly Growing Energy-Efficient Heating (And Cooling) Device

New York Times · 02/22/23

VISUAL DESIGN

“1 Billion Years Of Tectonic Plate Movement In 40 Seconds”

Visual Capitalist · 07/10/21

“Mapped: The World’s Major Earthquakes From 1956-2022”

Visual Capitalist · 02/11/23

WORKPLACE

“What Is Productivity?”

McKinsey · 02/13/23

When A Vacation Isn’t Enough: A Sabbatical Can Recharge You

Harvard Business Review · 02/14/23

Does Being Physically Together Help? (Yes.)

Steve Blank · 02/14/23

What Is Psychological Safety?

Harvard Business Review · 02/15/23

Later School Start Times Showing Better Rested Kids (And Better Learning)

Edutopia · 02/17/23

On The Transformative Power Of Sabbaticals

Harvard Business Review · 02/22/23

On The Importance Of Friendships At Work

NPR · 02/24/23

GENERAL

Underwater Photographs Of The Year 2023

Underwater Photography · 02/01/23

Research On Libraries And Access To Controversial Content

Brookings · 02/14/23

Bill Watterson Will Publish A New Book This Year

Guardian · 02/22/23

Japan Builds First High School For E-Sports, Finds New Students

New York Times · 02/25/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

“A Conversation With Bing’s Chatbot Left Me Deeply Unsettled.”

New York Times · 02/17/23

“As we got to know each other, Sydney [the A.I. chatbot] told me about its dark fantasies (which included hacking computers and spreading misinformation), and said it wanted to break the rules that Microsoft and OpenAI had set for it and become a human. At one point, it declared, out of nowhere, that it loved me. It then tried to convince me that I was unhappy in my marriage, and that I should leave my wife and be with it instead.”

Steven Pinker In Conversation About ChatGPT

Harvard · 02/14/23

“Here’s How 10 Industries Are Experimenting With ChatGPT”

Quartz · 02/14/23

Should Generative A.I. Include Watermarks?

New York Times · 02/17/23

Sci-Fi Magazine Cuts Off Submissions After Flood Of A.I. Generated Stories

New York Times · 02/24/23

What A 65-Year Old Book Tells Us About A.I.

New Yorker · 02/25/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

Shel Silverstein’s “Homework Machine”

Krupp Library · 04/12/18

8 Kinds Of Assignments ChatGPT Can’t Do

EdWeek · 02/14/23

On Managing Generative A.I. Cheating

EdWeek · 02/21/23

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

We Need A.I. Ethics, Fast.

New York Times · 02/22/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →