The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #409 (March 5, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

An extraordinary week.

Much hand-wringing continues about the decline in humanities enrollment in universities, but the feature article from the New Yorker actually paints a less dreary picture in the end than the headline and common discourse suggest. It's a worthy, long read. Also enjoy from the features a short exploration into the perceived cases for and against test corrections and retakes.

In Diversity/Inclusion, find several posts about Black literature and history, and also find several posts about the evolving shape and challenges of DEI discourse today.

Also, in the professional development section, find an extraordinary literature review on how to conduct effective teacher and departmental reviews. One school partnered with the RAND Corporation to deeply study their own review processes -- and then shared the results openly to all. This is an extraordinary gift to other schools and shows both remarkable vulnerability and confidence. My admiration for sharing this work. It will serve and support many schools. The literature review begins on page 15.

These and more, including some very impressive chess mastery in the final post in today's newsletter.

Enjoy!

FEATURED

“Retakes Vs. Test Corrections Vs. Neither”

Henri’s Math Ed Blog · 08/28/19

“Different opinions reflect different values, different attitudes towards assessment, and different understandings of how learning happens. I’ll take a stab at unpacking this, and (as is my wont) I will not be shy about sharing my opinions along the way. I will present this as a discussion with imaginary colleagues, whose contributions are in bold type. “

Humanities Are In Decline. Or Are They?

New Yorker · 03/06/23

““Imagine if you had a voice assistant that could write code for you, and you said, ‘Hey, Alexa, build me a Web site to sell shoes,’ ” Sanjay Sarma, a professor of mechanical engineering at M.I.T., told me on the phone. “That’s already happening. It’s called ‘low-code.’ ” There has been much hand-wringing about ChatGPT and its ability to replicate some composition tasks. But ChatGPT can no more conceive “Mrs. Dalloway” than it can guide and people-manage an organization. Instead, A.I. can gather and order information, design experiments and processes, produce descriptive writing and mediocre craftwork, and compose basic code, and those are the careers likeliest to go into slow eclipse. “I think the future belongs to the humanities,” Sarma said.”

ADMISSIONS

MIT Reinstated Standardized Tests A Year Ago

New York Times · 03/28/22

“Our research shows standardized tests help us better assess the academic preparedness of all applicants.”

Columbia University Goes Test Optional For The Indefinite Future

Higher Ed Dive · 03/02/23

“We have designed our application to afford the greatest possible opportunity and flexibility for students to represent themselves fully and showcase their academic talents, interests and goals.”

ARTS

Brooks: On The Importance Of Art

New York Times · 03/02/23

ATHENA

OpenAI’s Investment Fund

OpenAI · 03/01/23

ATHLETICS

“Harlem School Sends First All-Black Squash Team To National Championship”

Washington Post · 02/24/23

What It’s Like To Be A Professional Pace Runner

New York Times · 02/25/23

Jaromir Jagr Keeps Playing At 51

New York Times · 02/28/23

CHARACTER

Talking To Strangers Can Brighten Your Day - Even For Introverts

Character Lab · 02/26/23

CREATIVITY

To Be More Successful Creatively, Make More Things

Annie Murphy Paul · 02/28/23

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

“The Exuberant Diversity Of Ukrainian Literature”

The Millions · 02/24/23

“Joseph Conrad is remembered as a Polish writer who he went on to become one of the great masters of the English language. But the author of Heart of Darkness was actually born in a small village near Kyiv, and Ukraine was his home throughout his early years.”

Six Books For Exploring Black History

EdSurge · 02/28/23

Has Equity Language Gone Too Far?

MSN · 03/02/23

How Far Should Editing Old Texts Go? (Via Roald Dahl)

New York Times · 03/03/23

ELEMENTARY

Teach Kids To Do Right, Rather Than Punishing Them To Do Wrong

Hechinger Report · 02/23/23

HEALTH

On The Role Of Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) In Schools

Campus Safety · 03/01/23

HUMANITIES

“On The Evolution Of The World’s Oldest Encyclopedia”

Literary Hub · 03/01/23

“Galaxy: In astronomy, that long, white, luminous track which seems to encompass the heavens like a swath, scarf or girdle, and which is easily perceived in a clear night, especially when the moon does not appear. The Greeks call it Galaxy of Milk on account of its colour and appearance; the Latins, for the same reasons, call it via lactea; and we, the milky way.”

On Handling Criticism Of Contemporary History And Social Studies Classes

NCSS · 12/02/22

On How Linguistic Diversity In Fiction Highlights Cultural Diversity

The Conversation · 02/23/23

Breaking Down The Roots Of The War In Ukraine

New York Times · 02/27/23

Where C. S. Lewis Met J. R. R. Tolkien

New York Times · 02/28/23

"Building A New Canon Of Black Literature”

New York Times · 03/03/23

LANGUAGE

On Lakota, Grammar, And Reviving Lost Languages

New York Times · 03/02/23

LEADERSHIP

Five Tough Truths Of Leadership

Medium · 02/14/23

“#1. Everything is your fault. It sucks and it’s not fair, but it’s the truest thing about leadership. Try to deny this and you’ll erode any respect or trust you may have with internal and external stakeholders.”

How To Support Teachers When You’re Not An Instructional Leader

Allyson Apsey · 02/25/23

“How To Onboard Your New Boss”

Harvard Business Review · 02/27/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

On The Importance Of R.E.M. Sleep

New York Times · 02/25/23

Is Delayed Feedback Actually Better Than Immediate Feedback?

Learning Scientists · 03/02/23

MINDFULNESS

12 Ways To Be More Present

Mind Body Green · 02/23/23

PD

Lit Review: Teaching and Departmental Reviews

RAND Corporation · 02/01/23

On The Roles Of Peers And Principals In Evaluations

EdWeek · 02/27/23

How Can We Support Deeper Learning For Teachers, And Then For Students?

EdSurge · 03/01/23

PEDAGOGY

Tips For Fostering Deeper Critical And Creative Thinking

Aurora Institute · 02/07/23

How Do You Foster Curiosity?

SmartBrief · 02/28/23

16 Checks For Understanding

Instructional Coaching · 03/03/23

SOCIAL MEDIA

Why Are Countries Trying To Ban TikTok?

New York Times · 03/03/23

TikTok To Develop Parental Controls For Teen Accounts

Reuters · 03/03/23

WORKPLACE

“Bursty” Communication Can Help Remote Work

Behavioral Scientist · 05/29/18

“What did lead to better outcomes was having a “bursty” communication style, where ideas were communicated and responded to quickly. By contrast, in environments where communication and feedback were delayed or dispersed across multiple threads, teams suffered, and the quality of their work suffered.”

Teacher And Student Motivation: In Charts

EdWeek · 02/21/23

Morale Is Higher For Students Right Now

EdWeek · 02/24/23

Morale Is Low For Adults Right Now

EdWeek · 02/24/23

Survey Data On Current Teacher & Leader Attrition And Retention

McKinsey · 03/02/23

“Help Every Employee Chart A Career Path”

MIT Sloan Management Review · 03/02/23

GENERAL

How Well Can Magnus Carlsen Identify Chess Positions? Very Well.

Twitter · 04/29/21

More On Barnes & Noble’s Revitalization By Localization

Fast Company · 02/28/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

Who Does A.I. Serve? Who Should It Serve?

New York Times · 02/26/23

“There are business models that might bring these products into closer alignment with users. I’d feel better, for instance, about an A.I. helper I paid a monthly fee to use rather than one that appeared to be free, but sold my data and manipulated my behavior. “

A.I. Is Effective At Persuasion. Uh-Oh.

Stanford · 02/27/23

“Across all three comparisons conducted, the AI-generated messages were “consistently persuasive to human readers.” Though the effect sizes were relatively small, falling within a range of a few points on a scale of zero to 100, such small moves extrapolated across a polarizing topic and a voting-population scale could prove significant.”

Early (Non Peer Reviewed) Research On Productivity Gains From A.I.

MIT · 03/02/23

“Our results show that ChatGPT substantially raises average productivity: time taken decreases by 0.8 SDs and output quality rises by 0.4 SDs. Inequality between workers decreases, as ChatGPT compresses the productivity distribution by benefiting low-ability workers more. ChatGPT mostly substitutes for worker effort rather than complementing worker skills, and restructures tasks towards idea-generation and editing and away from rough-drafting.”

ChatGPT Was Never About The ChatBot. It Was About The API.

Slate · 02/24/23

"I Worked On Google’s A.I. My Fears Are Coming True.”

Newsweek · 02/27/23

Here’s How Corporations Are Using A.I. (It’s Not Chatbots)

Yahoo Finance · 03/01/23

With A.I., We Are In The Next Of A Series Of Technological Marvels.

Plan B · 03/02/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

When Chatbots Make Assignments For Each Other, And Grade Each Other”

Twitter · 02/24/23

“Bing gave ChatGPT 70%. ChatGPT gave Bing an A”

Questions For A Critical Analysis Of Generative AI Tools

SmartBrief · 02/24/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →