The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #414 (July 3, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Happy summer and holiday weekend, readers!

It's been an excellent break since the last issue, but I'm returning to the routine. New topics are urgently arising in preparation for this fall, and the news is awash with critical happenings:

• Advances in A.I. continue to complicate learning.

• Advances in A.I. also continue to supercharge learning.

• Supreme Court rulings are challenging diversity efforts.

• Admissions offices are innovating in response.

• The post-pandemic need for good governance grows.

• Social Media continues to cause concern.

• And on the positive and most essential, teaching & learning research continues to yield evidence of what makes for excellent practice.

This week's issue (which catches up on a few previous weeks) captures articles across these topics and much, much more.

On A.I., see the featured blog post by researcher Ethan Mollick on some of the key ways homework will need to evolve in the year ahead. Also see Nate Green's piece in Slate on the need for schools to act now (as in this summer) on how we will proactively set students and teachers up for success in a changed world with A.I.. Green highlights schools' failures (and culture's broader failure) to proactively engage the arrival of social media, and the cost of this is apparent in this week's social media articles, which show the challenges we are still facing today.

Clear policies and practices will help schools engage the emergence of A.I. both responsibly and in ways that empower student learning and teacher growth. Keep an eye on upcoming issues for more on this, and see the featured Learning Activities for the beginnings of a list that I will be accumulating of different practices for students and teachers alike.

Also see the other feature on how admissions offices might pivot in response to the Supreme Court ruling on affirmative action. Affirmative action helped countless students. See also how one student calls for something stronger. The best and boldest find ways to make a better future from even the most difficult losses.

Find all these and much, much more in this week's issue -- including the story of a 14 year old who made his own LEGO animation of Spiderman... and was called on by the producers to animate a scene in the actual film.

Enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

The Affirmative Action Ruling: “Five Ways College Admissions Could Change”

New York Times · 06/30/23

“The Supreme Court’s ruling on Thursday that ended race-conscious admissions is widely expected to lead to a dramatic drop in the number of Black and Hispanic students at selective colleges. But the court’s decision could have other, surprising consequences, as colleges try to follow the law but also admit a diverse class of students.”

“The Homework Apocalypse:” The Essay, Reading, And The Problem Set

One Useful Thing · 07/01/23

“Students will cheat with AI. But they also will begin to integrate AI into everything they do, raising new questions for educators. Students will want to understand why they are doing assignments that seem obsolete thanks to AI. They will want to use AI as a learning companion, a co-author, or a teammate. They will want to accomplish more than they did before, and also want answers about what AI means for their future learning paths. Schools will need to decide how to respond to this flood of questions. The challenge of AI in education can feel abstract, so to understand a bit more about what is going to happen, I wanted to examine some common assignment types… There is light at the end of the AI tunnel for educators, but it will require experiments and adjustment. In the meantime, we need to be realistic about how many things are about to change in the near future, and start to plan now for what we will do in response to the Homework Apocalypse. Fall is coming.”

ADMISSIONS

“Why Elite Colleges Can't Give Up Legacy Admissions”

KQED · 10/25/22

The Population Of School-Age Children Is Declining

New York Times · 06/14/23

ADOLESCENCE

Strong Relationships With Teachers Make A Big Difference For Student Futures

KQED · 06/05/23

Man Interviews His Daughter Annually For 17 Years. Here’s What He Learned.

NPR · 06/16/23

ARTS

“These Were The Most Performed Plays And Musicals In High Schools This Year”

NPR · 06/05/23

ATHLETICS

“Cumulative Force Of Head Hits… Increases Odds Of C.T.E.” (Cf. Concussions)

New York Times · 06/20/23

“The paper tried to address one of the most persistent challenges for brain trauma researchers: identifying what aspects of head hits contribute most to C.T.E. They looked at the number of hits to the head, the number of years playing football, the force of those hits and other factors. The best predictor of brain disease later in life, the study found, was the cumulative force of the head hits absorbed by the players over the course of their careers, not the number of diagnosed concussions.”

CHARACTER

“When Should You Let Your Kid Quit?”

KQED · 06/05/23

“One of the first obstacles is a reflexive negativity toward the idea of stopping something. Sloganeering about resilience and grit – “winners never quit and quitters never win,” for example – turn what should be rational decision making into a test of character. If we think of quitters as losers, we’ll err on the side of sticking with something that ought to be abandoned.”

Gratitude: More And More Research Shows It’s Good For Your Health

New York Times · 06/08/23

CREATIVITY

John Cleese On The Importance Of Free Play Without Fear Of Mistakes

Instagram · 05/30/23

CURRICULUM

Is Coding No Longer An Essential Skill For The Workforce?

New York Times · 06/02/23

““Programming will be obsolete,” Matt Welsh, a former engineer at Google and Apple, predicted recently… Welsh’s argument, which ran earlier this year in the house organ of the Association for Computing Machinery, carried the headline, “The End of Programming,” but there’s also a way in which A.I. could mark the beginning of a new kind of programming — one that doesn’t require us to learn code but instead transforms human-language instructions into software.”

Should Media Literacy Be Required?

Palo Alto Online · 06/06/23

“A 2019 Stanford University study, "Students' Civic Online Reasoning: A national portrait," found that two-thirds of students surveyed couldn't differentiate between editorial content and advertising, and 96% didn't understand why a climate-change website funded by a fossil fuel company might be suspect.”

An Iowa Program For Place- and Project-Based, Student-Driven Learning

74 Million · 05/24/23

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

“I'm In High School. I Hope Affirmative Action Is Rejected And Replaced With Something Stronger”

New York Times · 06/05/23

“Why Corporate America Is Worried About Affirmative Action”

New York Times · 06/20/23

HUMANITIES

Is The True Threat Of A.I. How It Will Weaken Human Institutions?

New York Times · 06/30/23

“But human intelligence is as much a product of policies and institutions as it is of genes and individual aptitudes. It’s easier to be smart on a fellowship in the Library of Congress than while working several jobs in a place without a bookstore or even decent Wi-Fi. It doesn’t seem all that controversial to suggest that more scholarships and public libraries will do wonders for boosting human intelligence. But for the solutionist crowd in Silicon Valley, augmenting intelligence is primarily a technological problem — hence the excitement about A.G.I.”

Jill Lepore, Constitutional Amendments, And The Need For Ongoing Change

New York Times · 07/01/23

“A written constitution ratified by the people — and subject to amendment by the people — is an American invention. In the 18th century, people who drafted constitutions and commented on constitutionalism came to agree that if such a strange, new and fragile thing as a written constitution were to endure, it would, as time passed, need to be both repaired and improved, mended and amended. To amend meant, at the time, to correct a fault; to repair an omission; to fix what’s broken; or to improve, in a moral sense: to make something better. The word shares a root, four of its five letters, and almost the entirety of its meaning, with the verb “mend.””

Cross-Cultural Differences In Graphic Novel Illustration

Taylor & Francis · 11/22/22

LANGUAGE

“You”: People Are More Engaged When You Speak In The Second Person

PNAS · 11/23/20

LEADERSHIP

5 Key Steps For Adaptive Leadership

NAIS · 05/16/23

6 Thinking Hats: Six Perspectives To Take Before Making A Decision

Mindtools · 05/23/23

“Understanding The Work Of [Trustee] Committee And Task Force Chairs”

NAIS · 06/01/23

On Building A More Diverse Board Of Trustees

NAIS · 06/01/23

On Building Your Board’s Skill Sets

NAIS · 06/01/23

A Scale For Agreement In Times Of Ambiguity

NAIS · 06/01/23

Is It Better To Ask Your Team for 85% Effort, Not 100%?

Harvard Business Review · 06/08/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

“How To Tell The Difference Between Regular Distraction And ADHD”

New York Times · 11/19/22

PD

Ongoing Research And Practice Lead To Important Incremental Improvement

British Medical Journal · 06/13/23

“For any given time since diagnosis, crude annual breast cancer mortality rates and risks decreased with increasing calendar period. Crude five year breast cancer mortality risk was 14.4% (95% confidence interval 14.2% to 14.6%) for women with a diagnosis made during 1993-99 and 4.9% (4.8% to 5.0%) for women with a diagnosis made during 2010-15.”

How Do Teachers Spend Professional Learning Time?

RAND Corporation · 06/01/23

PEDAGOGY

Some Basic Research: How Teacher Use Of Class Time Affects Student Performance

Science Direct · 04/17/23

“Students score higher in math when their teacher devotes more class time to individual practice and assessment. In contrast, students score higher in English if there is more discussion and work with classmates. Class time allocation predicts test scores separate from the quality of the teacher's instruction during the activities. These results suggest opportunities to improve student achievement without changes in teachers’ skills.”

How Teachers Use Class Time, And How It Impacts Performance

KQED · 06/19/23

“The researchers found that students who spent more time in class solving practice problems on their own and taking quizzes and tests tended to have higher scores in math. It was just the opposite in English class. Teachers who allocated more class time to discussions and group work ended up with higher scorers in that subject.”

Hattie: “A Meta-Analysis Of Ten Learning Techniques”

Frontiers In Education · 03/31/21

Adam Gopnik On Resisting Achievement Culture And Pursuing Passions

New York Times · 05/15/23

How To Best Support Learning-By-Teaching For Students

PsycNet · 06/01/23

Action-Oriented Feedback, More Than Praise, Helps Students Flourish

Scientific American · 06/15/23

READING/WRITING

Using Simpler Words Makes People Sound Smarter (Surprise!)

Big Think · 05/21/23

“Readers evaluate the intelligence of an author not only by the quality of their arguments but also by how well they understand what the author is trying to say. Using simple words and sentences makes the point clear. Big words don’t make writing sound intelligent; they make it hard to understand.”

On Ghostwriting: Notes From Prince Harry’s Ghostwriter

New Yorker · 05/08/23

SOCIAL MEDIA

“Teens Say Social Media Is Stressing Them Out. Here’s How To Help Them.”

KQED · 05/20/23

“Surgeon General Warns That Social Media May Harm Children And Adolescents”

New York Times · 05/23/23

For Some Students, Social Media Is A Lifeline

New York Times · 05/24/23

“How To Wean A Teen Off Social Media”

New York Times · 06/29/23

STEM

How Stereotypical CS Classroom Decor Marginalizes Girls

Learning Scientists · 06/25/23

“A.I. Is Coming For Mathematics, Too”

New York Times · 07/02/23

SUSTAINABILITY

A History Of Ancient Energy Sources, From Fire To Wind

Uncharted Territories · 05/23/23

TECH

The Case For Phone-Free Schools

Jonathan Haidt · 06/06/23

“The research is clear: Smartphones undermine attention, learning, relationships, and belonging.”

WORKPLACE

Six Macro Forces Affecting Organizations

NAIS · 04/18/23

Friday Early Release Made A Big Difference In This School District

We Are Teachers · 06/12/23

GENERAL

A 14-Year Old Animated One Of The Scenes In The New Spiderman Movie

New York Times · 06/07/23

“Preston Mutanga created a shot-for-shot version of the trailer with animated Lego characters. Then the producers asked him to work on the movie.”

Early Drafts Of Bohemian Rhapsody Had The Title “Mongolian Rhapsody”

New York Times · 05/31/23

Mississippi Schools Are Doing So Well. How Are They Doing It?

New York Times · 05/31/23

“Please Don’t Call My Job A “Calling”"

New York Times · 06/05/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

Microsoft Scientists Reflect On Human-Like Intelligence Of GPT-4

This American Life · 06/23/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

Now Is The Time To Plan How We — And Our Students — Will Engage A.I.

Slate · 06/26/23

“This summer, K–12 schools must get to work drafting academic policies governing the use of A.I. and facilitating professional development for teachers about the new technology. Educators need to address this trend head-on with students while simultaneously redesigning instruction and assessment in an age of A.I. We cannot start this work quickly enough.”

GPT Detectors Are Easily Bypassed

Cornell · 04/18/23

“New York City Does About-Face On ChatGPT In Schools”

EdWeek · 05/23/23

TECH/AI: GOVERNMENT AND LAW

Lawyer Uses ChatGPT, Didn’t Review The Work… Didn’t Go Well

New York Times · 05/27/23

“There was just one hitch: No one — not the airline’s lawyers, not even the judge himself — could find the decisions or the quotations cited and summarized in the brief. That was because ChatGPT had invented everything.”

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →