The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #415 (July 16, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Happy midsummer, all

It has been two extraordinary weeks -- not just of fireworks and family and friends, but also of developments in A.I. and learning. While the summer is yielding fascinating news and research on teaching and learning, cognitive science, pedagogy and more as always, the A.I. landscape is moving in leaps and bounds. It is almost unbelievable how quickly the field is advancing, and how much both euphoria and doom are circulating in the mediasphere.

For us in education, it is increasingly clear that schools have an enormous opportunity this fall: opportunities for professional growth for teachers, opportunities for customized learning for students, and opportunities for reimagined learning experiences.

It is also clear that every school should be feeling a sense of urgency about preparing for the fall term. This means leadership should be dedicating significant time at opening faculty meetings to share strategies for how the school will proactively navigate the emergence of A.I. Considerations might include:

• Will the school have an organization-wide policy on acceptable use of A.I. -- not only for students but also for faculty and staff?

• What professional learning will ensure all teachers are prepared not only to respond to student use of A.I., but to guide student use of A.I.?

• Has the school identified a lead team of teachers to drive discussion with the rest of the faculty about use of A.I.?

• What orientation will students have to set clear expectations for use of A.I. across their subjects?

• How will organizations like the school newspaper approach the use of A.I. in student writing? What about the literary magazine?

• Are members of the student life and IT offices prepared to handle student use of AI image and video generation?

I generally avoid grandiose statements about technology, but the world is changing, and it will be important to stay abreast of what is unfolding. If this is your domain, start with the second feature in today's issue, in which Ethan Mollick outlines the state of generative A.I. as of this month. Continue with the articles in the "Tech, AI" section(s) which I will be maintaining for the weeks ahead. Last, I will be slowly incrementally adding activities and exercises to Athena for students and teachers to understand what is possible with the new tools we have access to.

But also: the world remains the same. Human interactions remain the essence of what it means to live our fulfilling lives day to day. The first feature article offers a reminder from Psychology Today on what it means to have intellectual humility, to listen closely to others, and to understand that all people -- even those we vehemently disagree with -- believe their perspective to be true to them. How can we -- especially in a world of artificial intelligence -- remember that emotional intelligence is as much if not more important to living not just fully, but also happily.

So much more to also see this week: the politics of school plays, two pieces on the speed of learning, Taylor Swift studies (?!), pronouncing student names, the return of cursive, the importance of the staff room, and the educational value of board games.

All these and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

On Intellectual Humility, Really Listening, And Fighting Polarization (Cf. Discussion)

Psychology Today · 07/05/23

“The contemporary cultural machinery is geared to chase folks out of the middle ground or push experts in one area out of their lane, leading them to confidently pronounce on matters they have no business banging on about. Call it cognitive narcissism. Curious, collaborative inquiry has been abandoned for the brute force of unilateral persuasion. Intellectual humility, instead, courts the kind of nuance that’s often found in the middle ground.”

State Of Generative A.I. - July 2023 - An Orientation

One Useful Thing · 07/15/23

“I can’t claim that this is going to be a complete user guide, but it will serve as a bit of orientation to the current state of AI. I have been putting together a Getting Started Guide to AI for my students (and interested readers) every few months, and each time, it requires major modifications. The last couple of months have been particularly insane.”

ADMISSIONS

7 Essays On “Fixing” College Admissions

New York Times · 07/05/23

ADOLESCENCE

Don’t Give Your Tween A Smartphone

NPR · 07/12/23

ARTS

School Plays Are Increasingly The Subject Of School Politics

New York Times · 07/04/23

CHARACTER

John MacMurray On Reason And Emotion

Marginalian · 06/29/23

CREATIVITY

People Are More Creative Than Institutions

Social Science Research Network · 06/12/20

“In this study, we empirically assess the contributions of inventors and firms for innovation using a 37-year panel of U.S. patenting activity. We estimate that inventors’ human capital is 5-10 times more important than firm capabilities for explaining the variance in inventor output. We then examine matching between inventors and firms and find highly talented inventors are attracted to firms that (i) have weak firm-specific invention capabilities, and (ii) employ other talented inventors.”

CURRICULUM

Taylor Swift Studies? Classes On Taylor Swift Pervade Universities Today

LA Times · 07/07/23

“Earlier this year, another Stanford student taught a course on Swift’s 10-minute song “All Too Well.” Last year, classes about Swift’s songwriting and legacy thrilled Swifties at the University of Texas at Austin, Queen’s University in Ontario, Canada, and New York University — where Swift received her honorary doctorate alongside the Class of 2022. Rather than an excuse for fans to talk trivia and swap comfort songs, these courses seem to incorporate a measure of academic rigor. For example, the NYU class, taught by a Rolling Stone writer, examined Swift’s career in relation to feminism, race and the music industry. And at the University of Texas, students studied Swift’s songs alongside works from Shakespeare, Keats and Frost.”

“The Intercollegiate Civil Disagreement Partnership”

Stanford · 07/10/23

“Chen connected with his counterparts from ethics centers at four other institutions to form a consortium that represented students from a wide variety of backgrounds. The program has just completed its third year.”

On Knowledge And Learning: Wiggins, Wiebe, And Video Game Thinking

History Tech · 06/27/23

Four Essential Steps To Building A Profile Of A Graduate

Global Online Academy · 07/11/23

Should Data Science Be An Alternative To Algebra II?

New York Times · 07/13/23

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

Greta Gerwig Makes “Barbie” Into A Medium For Facing Real Issues

New York Times · 07/11/23

“Gerwig loves Barbie, but she knows Barbie has made people feel bad, as if they don’t measure up. And so she has made this 113-minute love letter to Barbie that is also an earnest attempt to make amends. This is the most subversive thing about the movie, this extratextual notion that Barbie might have things to make amends for. There is no reason Gerwig in particular should be the one trying to make those amends, except that she wanted to — to take an immense, divisive toy brand and bend it to the heartfelt and counterintuitive purpose of making women feel good.”

An illustrated Biography Of Henrietta Leavitt, Early Female Astronomer

Marginalian · 07/03/23

On Pronouncing Student Names Correctly

EdWeek · 07/13/23

HIGHER ED

Higher Ed And The Diverging Cost Of Education And Family Income

Professor Galloway · 07/07/23

HISTORY OF EDUCATION

A.I. Won’t Change The Heart Of Teaching, Even If It Will Change Learning

Larry Cuban · 06/16/23

“Similar claims about new technologies have been made before. Recall that, earlier generations of technophiles claimed that students using graphing calculators in class would transform math instruction (and raise test scores). Calculators surely helped students and teachers but did not alter dominant ways of teaching math.”

HUMANITIES

“What's The Difference Between Nationalism And Patriotism?”

The Conversation · 06/28/23

Why Does Storytelling Have Such Power Over Us?

New Yorker · 07/03/23

NYT Op-Doc On Video NPC’s And What They Say About Labor Today

New York Times · 07/11/23

LANGUAGE

Klingon, High Valyrian, Na’vi? Who Makes Up All These Languages?

Guardian · 07/07/23

“If a language offers clues to the culture of its speakers, then the experience of learning Game of Thrones’s High Valyrian on Duolingo conjures visions of a bustling historic civilisation in which owls stalk the skies, magic abounds, and the spectre of death forever haunts the imaginations of the living.”

LEADERSHIP

How To Spend Your First 90 Hours As A Leader

Harvard Business School · 04/11/23

That Weekly Meeting May Be The Most Important Thing You Do

Gallup · 05/30/23

4 Ways To Build Psychological Safety In Your Team

Harvard Business School · 06/14/23

Mindset Shifts Necessary When Leaping Into Leadership

Harvard Business Review · 07/01/23

Do You Read Situations Analytically, Contextually, Or Relationally?

Harvard Business School · 07/05/23

Develop A School Master Schedule With Your Leadership Team

Edutopia · 07/07/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

Students Learn At The Same Rate With Deliberate Practice

PsyArxiv · 01/17/23

“These findings pose a challenge for theories of learning to explain the odd combination of large variation in student initial performance and striking regularity in student learning rate.”

Does Slower = Smarter?

Big Think · 06/22/23

“Thus, while fast, “automatic” thinking is adequate for making decisions about easy tasks, a slower and more effortful mode of cognition, which supports the prolonged integration of relevant information, may be better for solving more difficult problems.”

PEDAGOGY

Prof Requires Students To Have A.I. Write Essay, Then They Grade It

Twitter · 05/27/23

“All 63* essays had hallucinated… The biggest takeaway from this was that the students all learned that it isn't fully reliable. Before doing it, many of them were under the impression it was always right. Their feedback largely focused on how shocked they were that it could mislead them. Probably 50% of them were unaware it could do this. All of them expressed fears and concerns about mental atrophy and the possibility for misinformation/fake news. One student was worried that their neural pathways formed from critical thinking would start to degrade or weaken.”

A Model For Great Teaching

Evidence Based Education · 07/01/23

An On-Ramp/Off-Ramp Metaphor For Universal Design For Learning

KQED · 07/02/23

READING/WRITING

New Yorker Writer Confronts An A.I. Modeled On His Own Writing

New Yorker · 07/11/23

“The generative text evokes a feeling in me not unlike the revulsion of hearing one’s own speaking voice in a recording. Do I really sound like that? The robot has made me acutely self-conscious. I recognize my A.I. doppelgänger, and I don’t like it.”

“Five Touchstones For Parents For Teaching Kids To Read”

KQED · 01/18/23

As Cursive Returns, Some Teachers Need To Learn It

CBC · 07/01/23

Having Students Read Their Writing Aloud Helps Catch Errors

Twitter/Edutopia · 07/05/23

SOCIAL MEDIA

Meta Introduces Threads. What Will Become Of Twitter?

New York Times · 07/11/23

“With 100 million people, Threads is quickly surging toward some of Twitter’s last public user numbers. Twitter disclosed it had 237.8 million daily users last July, four months before Mr. Musk bought the company and took it private.”

STEM

Wolfram Language Adds LLM Chatbot For Coding

Stephen Wolfram · 06/08/23

The A.I. Engineer: How Is A.I. Changing The Field Of Computer Science?

Latent Space · 06/30/23

How Should Data Science Change In The Age Of LLM AI?

Arxiv · 07/07/23

SUSTAINABILITY

Can Solar Energy Solve Global Warming?

Uncharted Territories · 07/11/23

TECH

“Cybersecurity Remains The Top Concern For School IT Leaders”

Ed Tech Magazine · 07/06/23

Podcast Pedagogy: An Excellent Way To Engage All Students

EdWeek · 07/10/23

WORKPLACE

On The Importance Of The Staff Room

Teacher Magazine · 08/22/17

Working From Home = 10-20% Productivity Loss. Hybrid Work = Gains

Stanford · 07/01/23

How Have Physical Classrooms (Not) Changed Over The Last Century?

Larry Cuban · 07/03/23

Dress Code: Are Yoga Pants Actually Pants?

New York Times · 07/03/23

Businesses Are Clamoring For Workplace A.I.

New York Times · 07/05/23

GENERAL

What Is Summer Learning Loss, And Is It A Problem?

Brookings · 01/30/23

On The Educational Benefit Of Board Games

CNN · 07/10/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

Rival to ChatGPT: Anthropic Launches Claude 2, Dedicated To Being “Good”

Guardian · 07/12/23

“A US artificial intelligence company has launched a rival chatbot to ChatGPT that… operates from a list of safety principles drawn from sources such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Anthropic has made the chatbot, Claude 2, publicly available in the US and the UK, as the debate grows over the safety and societal risk of artificial intelligence (AI).”

Wimbledon To Use AI-Generated Commentary

Guardian · 23-06-21

How Do Large Language Models (LLMs) Work? Via Austen, Shakespeare, Harry Potter, And More

New York Times · 04/27/23

One Company’s Template For Exploring How A.I. Can Work For Them

Odetta · 07/03/23

Doctor Describes Benefit Of A.I. In The E.R.

New York Times · 07/06/23

Can I Use ChatGPT For The Tedious Parts Of My Job?

New York Times · 07/07/23

Ethan Mollick On How To Use Code Interpreter With Data

One Useful Thing · 07/07/23

ChatGPT Can Now Crunch Numbers: Introducing Code Interpreter

New York Times · 07/11/23

A.I. Makers Fear They Are Creating An Existential Threat

New York Times · 07/11/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

Bryan Alexander Explores How Students Might Use A.I. In Higher Ed

AI In Academia · 07/07/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →