The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #428 (October 29, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

A fascinating week.

The features include a meaningful reflection on the humanities and a crisp reminder to celebrate teachers.

In this week's articles, find new data about the SAT, ideas for the upcoming Mexican holiday Dia de los Muertos, a raft of useful humanities links, practical pedagogical tips, and several posts about adolescent mental health, both in the Adolescence section and in Social Media. The theme of mental health also extends into the Gallup survey near the end suggesting that almost a quarter of the world feels lonely today.

These posts and more, including growing movement in A.I. governance in the A.I. Update at the end,

Enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

“Your Teachers Need A Win” - Tell Them How They Are Winning

Cult of Pedagogy · 10/22/23

“We are offering up ideas, strategies, new tools, fresh ways to fine-tune and improve and grow and it is all so well-intended, but to an overwhelmed teacher who is trying desperately to just keep their head above water, it’s like trying to drink from a firehose. The message ends up getting reduced down to one thing: DO MORE… So right now I want to pause my usual stream of ideas and suggestions and talk to those administrators, to principals and superintendents and instructional coaches and anyone else in a position to tell teachers how to do their jobs… So this is my ask of you as an administrator: Choose 10 teachers on your staff and make it a goal to give each of them one piece of specific, positive feedback this week.”

What Are The Humanities? What Is The “Burden” Of Teaching Them?

New Criterion · 11/01/23

“There is no happiness without unhappiness, or without the hard work of self-overcoming by which we become ourselves. We need to make sure that the future generations… understand why they should want to claim the right to be unhappy. And to be human. The body of knowledge that we call “the humanities” teaches that very lesson in a thousand texts and a thousand ways, for those who have been shown how to see and hear it. It is not a lesson that is readily on offer in our increasingly distracted world, and it is not grasped and absorbed without considerable effort. I believe that it will be the work of the humanities—the burden of the humanities—to remind us of it in the years to come, and of much else that we are ever more disposed to forget.”

ADMISSIONS

Kids Share College Admissions Stories On Social Media

EdSurge · 10/24/23

ADOLESCENCE

Charts: “How Educators And Teens Disagree On What’s Harming Students’ Mental Health”

EdWeek · 10/24/23

“13 Other Explanations For The Adolescent Mental Health Crisis. None of Them Work.”

Jonathan Haidt · 10/24/23

ASSESSMENT

Striking Data Correlating Wealth And SAT Performance

New York Times · 10/23/23

Meditation On Grade Inflation

New York Times · 10/23/23

SAT Test Takers Rebounds To 2017 Levels. Here’s A Data Deep Dive.

EdWeek · 10/25/23

CHARACTER

Four Principles For Deliberate Optimism In The Classroom

Middle Web · 10/26/23

CREATIVITY

Four Levels Of Creativity: Big-C, Pro-C, Little-C, and Mini-C

Aeon · 10/26/23

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

What Is Dia De Los Muertos? How Is It Celebrated Around The World?

Share My Lesson · 10/25/23

On Teaching “Killers Of The Flower Moon” With New Race Laws

EdWeek · 10/26/23

HUMANITIES

Simulating History In Extraordinary Ways With ChatGPT

Res Obscura · 09/12/23

“In the second half of this post, I go into detail about what exactly I mean by “simulating history.” I am under no illusions that these simulations are accurate: they are littered with confidently-stated falsehoods and hallucinations. Sometimes, though, hallucinations can be a feature, not a bug.”

“Discussing The Israel-Hamas War With Students Isn’t Easy. It Shouldn’t Be.”

EdWeek · 10/25/23

“It may be best to begin by reminding students that discussion in general is tough right now… The reasons for this can be traced back for decades, but we do know that social media is actively making it worse. Half of American adults say that they get their news from social media at least some of the time, and as many as 3 out of 4 overestimate their ability to identify “fake news.” …Simply making students aware of this challenge is a crucial first step. It should convince young people of the need to speak carefully, whatever their individual opinions may be. With that foundation in place, educators can equip them with the facts that they need for a constructive discussion by teaching them about the history of Israelis and Palestinians.”

A New Place to Learn Civics: The Workplace

New York Times · 10/29/23

“The training offerings vary. In Germany, media literacy has been a critical issue, while programs in the United States are frequently focused on teaching employees about how the government works and voting rights. But their basic premise is to empower employees to understand how their actions, both in and out of the workplace, affect the political climate and, ultimately, their own jobs.”

How To Talk With Kids About Mass Shootings, By Age Group

New York Times · 06/22/23

On Neutrality: “The Uses And Abuses Of The Kalven Report”

Chronicle of Higher Education · 10/24/23

Teacher Makes History Class Go Viral On TikTok and Insta With Gen Z-Style Videos

EdSurge · 10/24/23

The British Public Library Digitizes 25,000 Pre-1600 Manuscripts

Guardian · 10/25/23

Yale’s Avalon Project: Full Text Of Documents In Law, History, And Diplomacy

Yale · 10/29/23

LANGUAGE

New Support For The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis That Language Can Shape Thought

Scientific American · 11/01/23

“All human brains are of course the same, Nordlinger emphasized. But when people are putting thoughts into words, their mental processes may be different, depending on the language they are using.”

Start Languages Earlier For Greater Mastery

Economist · 05/10/18

“Which Languages Take The Longest To Learn?”

Economist · 09/18/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

Aphantasia: Close Your Eyes. Do You Actually See Images? Many People Don’t.

Kottke · 10/27/23

PD

“The Fundamentals Of Fast Feedback” On Classroom Visits

ASCD · 10/01/23

PEDAGOGY

Feedback In Practice: Before, During, And After

Global Online Academy · 10/24/23

“Small shifts in our feedback practices can lead to less work and more learning... These shifts are evolutionary, not revolutionary: they ask for modest and achievable adjustments in our pedagogy, not a wholesale overhaul.”

On How To Frame Questions: Use “You,” Diverse Examples, Or Classmates?

Chronicle of Higher Education · 10/26/23

“The researchers didn’t find any difference in academic performance or students’ sense of belonging or science identity based on which format of questions was used. But most students preferred the “you” format, explaining that it was the cleanest because it eliminated any extraneous information. And there were suggestions that it also helped students think about work they’d done in the lab and insert themselves into the problem.”

READING/WRITING

Written WIth Or Without A.I Doesn’t Matter: A Good Novel Is A Good Novel

Boston Review · 10/23/23

“On the page, the inherent polyphony of collaboration, however minor, becomes suppressed; the singular “I” is dissolved in the writing. Even traditional novels, which bear multiple rounds of revisions from editors and agents, succumb to this fate. A singular author might be credited on the cover, but the reality of authorship is often more collaborative and fluid than readers are led to believe… A good novel is a good novel, simple as that. A bad novel is also a bad novel, regardless of who—or what—wrote it. To bring it back to Calvino, the determinant of a novel’s quality remains the reader. We should retain a sense of optimism, then, about the future of literature.”

“When To Skim And When To Focus”

Edutopia · 10/19/23

SOCIAL MEDIA

33+ States Sue Meta Over Its Impact On Kids

EdWeek · 10/24/23

STEM

On The Role Of Computation And A.I. In The Computationally Irreducible Human Experience

Stephen Wolfram · 10/27/23

“In a sense, what’s happening is that Wolfram Language shifts from concentrating on mechanics to concentrating on conceptualization. And the key to that conceptualization is broad computational thinking. So how can one learn to do that? It’s not really a story of CS. It’s really a story of CX. And as a kind of education, it’s more like liberal arts than STEM. It’s part of a trend that when you automate technical execution, what becomes important is not figuring out how to do things—but what to do. And that’s more a story of broad knowledge and general thinking than any kind of narrow specialization.”

TECH

41 Questions To Ask Of Technology

The Convivial Society · 06/04/21

WORKPLACE

The Benefits And Risks Of Hybrid Work

Gallup · 09/29/23

“Teachers’ Stress Trickles Down To Students. What Can Schools Do?

EdWeek · 10/16/23

“What Teachers Say It Takes To Build A Positive School Culture”

EdWeek · 10/24/23

GENERAL

“17 Life-Learnings From 17 Years Of The Marginalian”

Marginalian · 10/22/23

“The Debt Collective” Wipes Out $10M In Student Loans — For $125K

Reckon · 10/23/23

“Almost A Quarter Of The World Feels Lonely”

Gallup · 10/24/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI

Adobe Offers Legal Coverage Against Copyright Violations

Fast Company · 06/08/23

“Adobe is so confident in Firefly’s ability to respect creators’ copyrighted images that it’ll legally compensate businesses if they’re sued for copyright infringement over any images its tool creates.”

Google Offers Legal Coverage Against Copyright Violations

Google · 10/12/23

“If you are challenged on copyright grounds, we will assume responsibility for the potential legal risks involved. To do this we will employ a two-pronged, industry-first approach designed to give you more peace of mind when using our generative AI products. The first prong relates to Google’s use of training data, while the second specifically covers generated output of foundation models.”

Artists Can Fight A.I. With Data Poisoning Techniques

MIT Technology Review · 10/23/23

“The tool, called Nightshade, messes up training data in ways that could cause serious damage to image-generating AI models.”

“A.I. Muddies Israel-Hamas War In Unexpected Way”

New York Times · 10/28/23

“Fakes related to the conflict have been limited and largely unconvincing, but their presence has people doubting real evidence.”

What Jobs Are Most Exposed To A.I.?

Harvard Business Review · 10/25/23

Use Image Seeds To Modify Images In DALLE-3

Twitter · 10/25/23

Some Guidance On Leveraging Generative AI To Support Decision-Making

Harvard Business Review · 10/26/23

Thirty A.I. Tools For Different Work Needs

Twitter · 10/27/23

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

Early Learning For A.I. Designers From Working With Teachers

Stanford · 10/18/23

“The scholars originally assumed that math teachers first pick a strategy to help the student understand. But after interviewing math teachers, they learned that a teacher’s first step is to try to pinpoint exactly where the student’s misconception is coming from… When they asked students to rate the feedback generated by LLMs and teachers, the math teachers were always rated higher. However, when they re-prompted the LLM with help from the teachers — who labeled the type of student mistake and offered a specific strategy to use — the LLM responses were rated much higher. While still not considered as valuable as a teacher, the LLMs rated more highly than a layperson tutor.”

Parents Are Open To A.I. Use In Schools. But They Have Questions.

EdWeek · 10/20/23

“Four in 10 parents say they know a “little general information” about artificial intelligence, and about six in 10 say they have heard little to nothing about how AI can be applied in education… Even so, the majority of parents—more than two thirds—believe that the potential benefits of AI to K-12 education either outweigh or are equal to the potential drawbacks. Only 16 percent of parents feel that the downsides outstrip any potential benefits.”

What Is Cheating? Here Are 12 Gradations Of Writing With A.I.

Ditch That Textbook · 08/29/23

On Using ChatGPT In Writing: A Few Stories From The Classroom

Hechinger Report · 10/26/23

Suggested Key Competencies In The “Age Of Collective Intelligence”

Rooted · 10/26/23

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

Leading Global Academics Call For Management Of A.I. Risks

Managing A.I. Risks · 10/24/23

“Yuval Noah Harari… Daniel Kahneman… In this short consensus paper, we outline risks from upcoming, advanced AI systems. We examine large-scale social harms and malicious uses, as well as an irreversible loss of human control over autonomous AI systems. In light of rapid and continuing AI progress, we propose urgent priorities for AI R&D and governance.”

TECH/AI: GOVERNMENT AND LAW

U.N. Announces A.I. Advisory Body On A.I. Governance

United Nations · 10/27/23

“Bringing together experts from government, the private sector, the research community, civil society, and academia, the Body’s global, gender-balanced and interdisciplinary makeup will help it play a unique role in helping AI work for humanity. The Body’s immediate tasks include building a global scientific consensus on risks and challenges, helping harness AI for the Sustainable Development Goals, and strengthening international cooperation on AI governance.”

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →