The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #429 (November 12, 2023)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

An excellent week.

I'm (selfishly) featuring this week a blog post I wrote in which I read Disney's "The Sorcerer's Apprentice" through the lens of our current cultural moment with artificial intelligence. The tale, in which Mickey plays a hapless apprentice wielding powerful magic, is actually nearly 2000 years old and has been adapted and readapted over the centuries. A cautionary tale, it prompts meaningful questions for us to ask today. It's the second feature below. I hope you'll check it out.

Also featured this week is some provocative work coming out of Teachers College about the effect of student choice and character complexity on reading. See the first feature below.

Also this week: reflections on assessments, re-conceiving the humanities, cognitive science reminders, and more.

And, some big moves in the A.I. update at the end, including individually customizable bots coming from OpenAI, a White House Executive Order, new prompt frameworks, and more.

All these, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

“What Happens When Young People Actually Read ‘Disturbing’ Books”

Teachers College · 10/31/23

“Four eighth-grade English language arts teachers, initially most concerned about their students’ disinterest in reading, stopped assigning any particular book and instead gave students wide access to books written for young adults, let them choose what to read (or not), and gave them time to read and openly discuss the books. We studied these classrooms for two years and followed some students two years into high school… Here’s what we learned. The students, most of whom reported previously reading little or nothing, started reading like crazy—in and out of school—and their reading achievement improved. While this was the initial motivation for the teachers, it became the least interesting outcome. Students reported becoming better people, a change also noticed by their parents and peers. Reading engaging narratives about characters with complicated lives, they reported, helped them become more empathetic, less judgmental, more likely to seek multiple viewpoints, morally stronger, and happier. Yes, happier. They reported improved self-control, and building more and stronger friendships and family relationships.”

The Sorcerer’s Apprentice: A Case Study In A.I. And Playing With Magic

Sense and Sensation · 11/12/23

“If we follow the tale, this all might be ok in the end.  Eucrates learned his lesson — when asked to perform the magic, he says, “if it once becomes a water carrier… we shall be obliged to let the house be flooded with the water that is poured in!”  His lesson is much like the cautionary words of Mustafa Suleyman, founder of Inflection AI, in an interview with the Center for Human Technology: “The challenge for the next century is going to be what we don't do rather than what we do.” Perhaps we can learn this lesson, too.  But what does that look like in practice, and how do we learn it collectively?”

ADMISSIONS

How Did Test Optional Admissions Go?

Higher Ed Dive · 10/30/23

ADOLESCENCE

Detailed Information On High School Suicide Rates

After Babel · 10/30/23

“Vaping Declines Sharply Among Older Teens But Rises For Middle Schoolers”

EdWeek · 11/02/23

ASSESSMENT

Reflections On Assessments In A Time Of A.I.

Rooted · 10/31/23

“What all this means is that human thinking can be made explicitly visible if we invite students to do work complex enough to be worthy of our unique, organic cognitive capacities. Based on this research, I recommend the following indicators as a way to verify and evaluate an assessment or performance task's level of complexity:”

“I Used To Think I Was A Fair Grader. Now, I Look Back And Cringe”

EdWeek · 11/02/23

There’s A Growing Gap Between Test Scores And GPA

Brookings · 11/06/23

CHARACTER

Brief Notes On Curiosity From Angela Duckworth

Character Lab · 11/01/23

“4 Phrases That Build A Culture Of Curiosity”

Harvard Business Review · 11/01/23

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

“Women In The Workplace 2023” Report and Recommendations

McKinsey · 10/05/23

Survivor Of The 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre Awaits A Day In Court

New York Times · 11/07/23

HEALTH

“A Playbook For Student And Teacher Well-Being”

Middle Web · 11/09/23

“Educators faced with the reality that they cannot fix everything may be suffering from compassion fatigue. That could be summed up as a “combination of physical, emotional, and spiritual depletion.” (p.6) That’s why the authors address you first in each module before focusing on students and the school.”

Fall Flu/Illness Season: November State Of Affairs

Your Local Epidemiologist · 10/31/23

HIGHER ED

“Fall 2023 Enrollment Trends In 5 Charts”

Higher Ed Dive · 10/30/23

“Universities Can’t Accommodate All The Computer Science Majors”

Inside Higher Ed · 11/02/23

HUMANITIES

The Humanities Are Expansive: We Should See Them As Such

Inside Higher Ed · 10/25/23

“The prestige disciplines in the humanities— law, economics, government—enjoy broad cultural understanding and appreciation of their social value. They could teach the more niche disciplines—literary studies, philosophy, the arts—how to be more publicly engaged. At the same time, the enterprise of the humanities in general benefits from a wide cultural understanding that these disciplines are on the same team.”

Visualizations Of Dante’s Hell, From The Renaissance To Today

Open Culture · 06/12/18

Lester Del Ray And The Birth Of Popular Fantasy Fiction

Slate · 10/01/23

How Some Teachers Are Responding To Student Inquiries About The Israel-Hamas War

EdWeek · 10/30/23

Meanwhile, Humanities Are Increasingly At Risk Of Being Cut

New York Times · 11/03/23

LANGUAGE

“Latinos’ Views Of And Experiences With The Spanish Language”

Pew Research · 09/20/23

“How ‘Blue’ And ‘Green’ Appeared In A Language That Didn’t Have Them”

MIT · 11/02/23

LEADERSHIP

The Importance Of “Positive Relational Energy” From Leaders

Harvard Business Review · 04/18/22

“It’s Time For Boards To Take A.I. Seriously”

Harvard Business Review · 11/02/23

The Big Things And The Little Things For Success As A CEO

LinkedIn · 11/02/23

LEARNING SCIENCE

“Flashcards Prevail Over Repetition In Memorizing”

Hechinger Report · 10/30/23

Interleaving Is Always Better Than Blocking, According To Study

Learning Scientists · 11/02/23

What’s Happening In Your Brain When It Retrieves Words?

The Conversation · 11/07/23

READING/WRITING

Claude Shannon, Italo Calvino, Generative A.I. And The Future Of Reading

Hedgehog Review · 10/01/23

A Brief History Of The Open Stack Library

Res Obscura · 11/08/23

Should We Still Teach Sight Words? (Yes.)

Shanahan On Literacy · 11/11/23

SAFETY

School Cyberattacks Continue To Rise

The 74 Million · 11/08/23

STEM

The Discovery Of Electricity Led To Parlor Performances Of Its Power

Lapham’s Quarterly · 11/01/23

“Bose, who performed for the duchess of Gotha, designed an experiment that turned ladies into electric Venuses. For this demonstration, which he called “Venus electrificata” and which Franklin later renamed the “electric kiss,” a lady stood on an insulated stool while a gentleman tried to kiss her, only to receive painful sparks from her lips. Gentlemen, in their turn, could perform their virility by “inflaming spirits,” that is, setting fire to alcohol with electrified swords. For those who preferred a less aggressive model of masculinity, Bose designed an electric “beatification,” which made a luminous halo appear above a person’s head.”

Stunning, Beautiful Exploration Of The Impact Of The James Webb Telescope

New York Times · 11/05/23

SUSTAINABILITY

“Electric Planes, Once A Fantasy, Start To Take To The Skies”

New York Times · 11/03/23

TECH

What’s The History And Research Around Cellphone Bans

New York Times · 10/31/23

The Impact Of Cellphone Bans As Told Through Several Schools

New York Times · 10/31/23

"Ten Ways Parents Can Keep Kids Safe Online”

Campus Safety · 11/03/23

WORKPLACE

Plants In The Classroom Are Good For Learning, It Turns Out

EdWeek · 10/27/23

“Additional studies have found that K-12 students’ concentration, focus, and test scores improve when they have plants in the classroom.”

One Obstacle To Sleep And Late-Start Schedules: Bus Logistics

KFF Health News · 11/06/23

Alternatives To Email: Office Hours And Standing Team Meetings

Cal Newport · 11/10/23

GENERAL

Clothes With Patterns Designed By Bacteria

Fast Company · 10/24/23


A.I. Update

TECH/AI: FEATURED

The Open Empathic Project: Bringing Empathy To A.I.

TechCrunch · 10/27/23

““With Open Empathic, our goal is to create an AI that goes beyond understanding just words,” Schuhmann added. “We aim for it to grasp the nuances in expressions and tone shifts, making human-AI interactions more authentic and empathetic.””

“Everyone Knows Claude Doesn’t Show Up On A.I. Detectors”

Academic Platypus · 11/07/23

“I was talking [with my son] about how bad AI detectors are, and that they should all be banned and I was complaining that one of my students told me that his professor was actually marking down students if their work showed up in the AI detector in TurnItIn when, out of the blue, he offered the following: “Your student should use Claude AI. Everyone knows that Claude doesn’t show up on AI detectors.”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

“Teachers: Don’t Use A.I. Detectors”

The Algorithmic Bridge · 07/26/23

NYC’s About-Face: From Banning A.I. To Creating A.I. Policy Lab

EdWeek · 10/05/23

A.I. And Bloom’s Taxonomy: How Well Does It Perform?

Getting Smart · 10/31/23

Admissions Offices Explore GenAI For Their Work

Chronicle of Higher Education · 11/01/23

Teacher + ChatGPT Accelerates ChatGPT Capabilities

Dan Meyer · 11/01/23

Princeton Prof Walks Through A Writing Assignment Using ChatGPT

EdSurge · 11/03/23

Excellent Walkthrough Of A College History Assignment With ChatGPT

e-Literate · 11/06/23

Some Schools Are Using Permission Slips For ChatGPT

EdWeek · 11/07/23

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

On "Encoding Societal Values Into Social Media A.I.s”

Stanford · 10/20/23

“Values centered on individual experience, such as personal agency, enjoyment, and stimulation, are undeniably important and central requirements for any social media platform. It shouldn't be surprising that reward hacking only on individual values will lead to challenging societal-level outcomes, because the algorithm has no way to reason about societies. But then, what would it even mean to algorithmically model societal-level values? How would you tell an algorithm that it needs to care about democracy in addition to agency and enjoyment?”

Hackers Are Leveraging A.I. To Enhance Phishing Attacks

The Messenger · 10/30/23

“Microsoft is already seeing cyber criminals and government hackers “using AI to refine the language that they use in their phishing attacks … and make them somewhat harder to detect,” Tom Burt, the company’s corporate vice president of customer security and trust, told reporters during a recent briefing.”

Max Tegmark Describes The Tech Industry’s Fear Of A.I. Driven Extinction

TED · 10/01/23

How Real Are The Greatest Fears About A.I.?

Business Insider · 10/31/23

U.K. Hosts 1st International A.I. Safety Summit

Quartz · 11/03/23

TECH/AI: GOVERNMENT AND LAW

Artist Lawsuits Against A.I. Companies Struggle To Gain Traction

Reuters · 10/30/23

“U.S. District Judge William Orrick dismissed some claims from the proposed class action brought by Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan and Karla Ortiz, including all of the allegations against Midjourney and DeviantArt. The judge said the artists could file an amended complaint against the two companies, whose systems utilize Stability's Stable Diffusion text-to-image technology. Orrick also dismissed McKernan and Ortiz's copyright infringement claims entirely. The judge allowed Andersen to continue pursuing her key claim that Stability's alleged use of her work to train Stable Diffusion infringed her copyrights. The same allegation is at the heart of other lawsuits brought by artists, authors and other copyright owners against generative AI companies.”

White House Issues Executive Order On A.I. Regulation/Adoption

New York Times · 10/30/23

Official White House Fact Sheet On The Executive Order On A.I.

whitehouse.gov · 10/30/23

Full (Very Long) Text Of The White House Executive Order On A.I.

whitehouse.gov · 10/30/23

Government Memo For Applying A.I. To Government Functions

AI.gov · 11/01/23

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

David Wiley: The Impact Of Generative A.I. In One Sentence

Open Content · 10/17/23

“Generative AI greatly reduces the degree to which access to expertise is an obstacle to education… We haven’t even started to unpack the implications of this notion yet, but hopefully just naming it will give the conversation focus, give people something to disagree with, and help the conversation progress more quickly.”

Game-Changer: Customize Your A.I. With Documents, Principles, Data

OpenAI · 11/06/23

“We’re rolling out custom versions of ChatGPT that you can create for a specific purpose—called GPTs. GPTs are a new way for anyone to create a tailored version of ChatGPT to be more helpful in their daily life, at specific tasks, at work, or at home—and then share that creation with others. For example, GPTs can help you learn the rules to any board game, help teach your kids math, or design stickers. Anyone can easily build their own GPT—no coding is required.”

You Can Customize Your Own GPT For Your Own Classes And Teaching

One Useful Thing · 11/07/23

“While everyone benefits from feedback on their writing, not everyone has access to an expert editor or teacher, and many students get feedback only rarely. So we created a GPT to provide specific, actionable feedback… Then, rather than just writing the essay for the student, the GPT returns an edited, marked in red copy of the Word document with advice based on rubrics. This is obviously a prototype, but the fact that writing instructors can now create a GPT that can provide personalized advice in their personal style, and then give that GPT away to people all over the world to improve their writing, is exciting.”

“Personalized A.I. Agents Are Here”

New York Times · 11/10/23

“They differ from the regular ChatGPT in a few important ways. First, they are programmed for specific tasks. (Examples that OpenAI created include “Creative Writing Coach” and “Mocktail Mixologist,” a bot that suggests nonalcoholic drink recipes.) Second, the bots can pull from private data, such as a company’s internal H.R. documents or a database of real estate listings, and incorporate that data into their responses. Third, if you let them, the bots can plug into other parts of your online life — your calendar, your to-do list, your Slack account — and take actions using your credentials.”

How Does ChatGPT Work? An Excellent Longread

Stephen Wolfram · 02/14/23

Beyond Prompt Engineering: Interactive Task Elicitation

Arxiv · 10/17/23

Adding Emotion To Prompts Seems To Impact Outcomes

Arxiv · 10/20/23

Two Kinds Of A.I. Prompts: Conversational And Technical

One Useful Thing · 11/01/23

How to Build A Personal, Custom GPT In Four Minutes [Video]

OpenAI · 11/07/23

TECH/AI: USES AND APPLICATIONS

People Are Speaking With A.I. For Hours

Ars Technica · 10/27/23

“Starhaven recently wrote, "My new morning driving routine involves chatting with ChatGPT through my car speaker/Airplay, as if I were hanging on the phone with my mum." He talked about working through ideas vocally. "Sometimes you just wanna share your unhinged thoughts with a friend—though, maybe not at 7 in the morning," he wrote. "So when OpenAI rolled out this feature a few weeks back, I found the perfect solution to my problem and, incidentally, a creative way of surviving the drudgery that is Belgian traffic jams.”"

Process For Adopting A.I. In Health Care Needs Attention

New York Times · 10/30/23

“A.I. Twice As Accurate As A Biopsy At Grading… Some Sarcomas”

Institute for Cancer Research · 11/01/23

Senegalese Student Uses A.I. To Help Eradicate Malaria

New York Times · 11/03/23

TECH/AI: OTHER

Bill Gates On The Future With A.I. Agents

Gates Notes · 11/09/23

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →