The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #446 (May 12, 2024)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

On effective writing instruction, teaching math, consistency in grading practices, and ongoing issues surrounding free speech about diversity in America and politics in the Middle East

An excellent week full of useful teaching & learning pieces as well as today’s complex topics.

In today’s features, find a meta-analysis of what works in writing instruction. This research article is a technical read, but it looks broadly at hundreds of studies to identify the validity and strength of different approaches, and combing through it can yield some helpful guidance. Also in today’s features, see a report by RAND on how restrictions on discussions of race and gender in the classroom have affected teachers.

Also this week, find a robust STEM section on teaching math and coding: the importance of teachers in student math progress, how AI copilots are changing the way students learn CS, and more.

Also, while campus protests and arrests around the war in Gaza extend into the final weeks of school and even some graduation ceremonies, find reports of how the moment is playing out both in colleges and in schools. See also a report on how these protests are being received in pockets of Gaza. For me, having lived in the Middle East for four years, the events in Israel and Gaza have hit close to home.

Last, if you are interested in the great cicada emergence of 2024, check out the two articles in the general section near the end. This year, two enormous cicada broods are emerging at once. See the posts below for historical maps of these emergences over the past 200 years as well as an excellent visual explainer of what is happening this year.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

A Technical Meta-Analysis Of What Works In Writing Instruction

Research Gate · 10/01/23

“In this meta-analysis, we examined if teaching writing improved the writing and reading of students in Grades 6 to 12, and what specific writing treatments enhanced students’ writing. Our review included writing treatments tested using an experimental or quasi-experimental design (with pretests) and published and unpublished studies, and computed effect sizes for all writing and reading outcomes assessed.”

How Have Restrictions On Race And Gender In Classroom Content Affected Teaching And Learning?

RAND Corporation · 03/12/24

“As of spring 2023, 3 percent of teachers said that limitations on race- or gender-related topics positively impact student learning. Teachers were about ten times more likely to say that such limitations negatively impact student learning. Teachers who opposed limitations voiced concerns that these limitations constrain students' learning opportunities, diminish students' sense of belonging and capacity for empathy, and could lead to long-term consequences for students' futures and the future of the education system, country, and democracy. The few teachers who supported limitations believed that race or gender are topics more appropriate for discussing at home than at school. They noted that emphasizing race or gender in the classroom is developmentally inappropriate for young students, creates division and confusion among students, and shifts the focus away from academic learning.

ARTS

“What Beethoven’s Ninth Teaches Us”

New York Times · 05/06/24

“Ludwig van Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony was first performed exactly 200 years ago Tuesday and has since become probably the work most likely to be embraced for political purposes. It was played at the 1936 Olympic Games in Berlin; it was performed in that city again on Christmas 1989 after the fall of the Berlin Wall, when Leonard Bernstein replaced the word “Joy” in the choral finale with “Freedom”; the European Union adopted the symphony’s “Ode to Joy” theme as its anthem.”

A Wonderful Retelling Of Beethoven’s Composition Of The Ode To Joy

Marginalian · 05/17/22

ASSESSMENT

Thomas Guskey On “Addressing inconsistencies In Grading Practices”

Kappan · 04/29/24

ATHLETICS

How “Progressive Overload” Helps In Strength Training

New York Times · 05/09/24

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

Are The Chicago Principles Undemocratic?

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 05/06/24

“The Chicago Principles equate freedom of expression with freedom of discussion. The problem with this equation is that discussion is not the only mode of rational public speech: it differs from deliberation, on the one hand, and from protest, on the other. Discussion is truth-seeking speech; deliberation is decision-making speech; and protest is disruptive speech. All three are hallmarks of democracy, but only the first is protected by the Chicago Principles.”

Play By Play: How One University President Is Engaging With Protestors

New Republic · 05/07/24

“It’s almost the end of the school year, and more than once I’ve been asked, “Don’t I wish we had just made it through a couple of more weeks without incident?” Mostly … no. How can I not respect students for paying attention to things that matter so much? I respect that they’re concerned about Gaza; I admire that they’re not entirely taken up with grades or lining up their credentials… I also think student protesters are wrong to focus on university investments. I would prefer they use their energies to pressure the U.S. government to do more to get the hostages released, to stop supporting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s war tactics, and to bring more direct aid to people in Gaza on the brink of starvation. My team expects to discuss all of this with students in the coming days. Right now, I’m most concerned with protecting their right to protest in nonviolent ways that don’t undermine our educational program.”

“Some Gazan’s Say US Campus Protests Give Them “Hope”

New York Times · 05/01/24

“70 Years After Brown v Board of Education, New Research Shows Rise In School Segregation”

Hechinger Report · 05/06/24

How School Committee Meetings Have Fractured In Berkeley Public Schools

New York Times · 05/07/24

“A Virginia County Board Votes To Restore Confederates’ Names To Schools”

NPR · 05/10/24

ELEMENTARY

“Kindergarten Math Is Often Too Basic. Here’s Why That’s A Problem.”

Hechinger Report · 05/02/24

HEALTH

“Are We Talking Too Much About Mental Health?”

New York Times · 05/06/24

“Some researchers warn that we are in danger of overdoing it. Mental health awareness campaigns, they argue, help some young people identify disorders that badly need treatment — but they have a negative effect on others, leading them to over-interpret their symptoms and see themselves as more troubled than they are.”

Some Approaches To Countering Loneliness

New York Times · 05/06/24

HIGHER ED

The Number Of Male Applicants To College Is Declining

Hechinger Report · 05/03/24

“The number of men enrolled in college nationwide has dropped by more than 157,000, or almost 6 percent, in just the last five years, according to the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center. The proportion of college students who are men is now a record-low 41 percent, the U.S. Department of Education says.”

“Micro-credentials In The Humanities Are On The Rise”

Inside Higher Ed · 05/08/24

“Such findings indicate that despite “a push toward narrow technical training and STEM initiatives at the expense of humanities programs,” the labor force demands more than just technical skills from graduates.”

HUMANITIES

What Is The Viability Of A Two State Solution?

Stanford · 05/07/24

“Former Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad and Israeli Professor Alon Tal explored the complexities and potential of a two-state solution through a model of civil discourse.”

What Is “Wilderness”?

Hedgehog Review · 04/01/24

Plato’s Final Hours Recounted In Recently Deciphered Scrolls

Guardian · 04/29/24

“John Guillory On The Future Of Literary Criticism”

Public Books · 05/02/24

“In A Poem, Just Who Is “The Speaker,’ Anyway?”

New York Times · 05/08/24

LEARNING SCIENCE

On The Theory, Practice, And The Future Of The Science Of Learning

TES · 05/01/24

“One thing that unites these varied researchers is a dedication to developing abstracted, idealised, value-free models of learning. What predictable patterns does memory follow? What function does attention play in perception? How does motivation influence social engagement?”

What Do We Give Up When AI Takes Notes For Us?

Marc Watkins · 05/10/24

“For every utopian-styled use case we imagine for this technology and its impact on student learning, we must balance it with the ways these tools are increasingly marketed on social media to students not as a learning aid, but as another method to disengage and check out of the learning process.”

On Handwriting Vs Typing, And Which Is Better For Synthesis

NPR · 05/11/24

PD

Where Teacher Evaluation Movements Went Wrong

Fordham Institute · 05/03/24

PEDAGOGY

What To Do When Student Refuse To Work

Edutopia · 04/26/24

“As educators grapple with the silent protest of student work refusal, research illuminates the underlying causes—and possible solutions.”

“Why Play Is Serious Work”

Brookings · 05/02/24

READING/WRITING

On The Real Risk Of AI’s Impact On Reading

Marc Watkins · 05/03/24

“The implications of having an AI-reading assistant that can summarize anything into your language, at your reading level, can have immense benefits for neurodiverse learners and second-language learners. AI reading assistants could play an important role in equity and access to information. However, the uncritical adoption of AI reading tools poses an incredible risk to student’s close reading skills.”

SAFETY

“More Than 30 States Allow Teachers To Carry Guns”

Campus Safety · 05/10/24

“Just 17 states and the District of Columbia have laws specifically prohibiting teachers from carrying guns. However, even those laws can vary, as denoted in the list below.”

“5 Types Of School Emergency Drills”

Campus Safety · 05/10/24

STEM

On The Critical Role Of Teachers In Student Progress In Math

RAND Corporation · 03/19/24

“Who wields significant influence in how students are tracked? Teachers. Of the principals who reported that students were in some way grouped by achievement level, more than 80 percent reported using teacher recommendations as one consideration when making their decisions. Researchers say that teachers should recognize the critical role they can play in determining students’ futures. For instance, the way teachers decide to group students within their own classes could easily lead to a decision to group a child into a lower-track class in the future. And teachers’ recommendations could make a difference in whether a child is placed into more challenging math classes.”

“AI Copilots Are Changing How Coding Is Taught”

IEEE · 05/02/24

“High School Math Can Be Playful, Too”

KQED · 05/06/24

“When Are Students Ready For Algebra I?”

K12 Dive · 05/08/24

SUSTAINABILITY

“Giant Batteries Are Transforming The Way The US Uses Electricity”

New York Times · 05/07/24

Tech Is The New Energy Sector

Professor Galloway · 05/10/24

WORKPLACE

Data Suggests Enrollment In Teacher Training Is Growing

74 Million · 04/28/24

“From 2018 through 2022, enrollment in teacher preparation programs grew 12% nationally, or by about 46,231 more candidates, according to a March report on Title II data from Pennsylvania State’s Center for Evaluation and Education Policy Analysis.”

One Way To Appreciate Teachers: Provide Day Care

AP News · 05/07/24

What Rights To Free Speech Do Public School Teachers Have?

New York Times · 05/07/24

GENERAL

On Visualizing A Lifespan

Wait But Why · 12/11/15

“Each of those dots is only a single Tuesday or Friday or Sunday, but even a lucky person who lives to 90 will have no problem fitting every day in their life on one sheet of paper.”

Historical Cicada Maps In The United States

New York Times · 05/02/24

“Brood XIII and Brood XIX will emerge together this year, for the first time in more than two centuries.”

“A Visual Guide To 2024’s Rare Dual [Cicada[ Appearance”

CNN · 05/03/24

“Billions of bugs are emerging from the soil across a large swath of the United States in a natural phenomenon last witnessed in 1803. It involves two broods, or groups, of periodical cicadas, insects with relatively long life cycles that show up after a certain interval. The Northern Illinois brood spends 17 years underground before surfacing and is known as Brood XIII, while the Great Southern Brood, or Brood XIX, lives underground for 13 years… The synchronous dual emergence of these two particular broods, which happens once every 221 years, is underway until June. The next time the two broods appear together, it will be 2245.”

Apple Whiffed On The iPad Commercial, But Won On The Find My Friends Ad

YouTube · 05/03/24


A.I. Update

AI growth in the workplace, tips for teaching about deepfakes, OpenAI's "model spec" and more

Some important pieces published this week.

The first feature highlights an excellent resource put out by AI for Education to help educators and students navigate the increasing appearance of deepfakes in society. This is a much needed and very helpful guide.

Also, to understand just how much AI is emerging in the workplace, explore Microsoft’s AI Workplace Trends report. Not only is AI increasingly common in the workplace, but it is also leading to higher levels of job satisfaction. The challenge, however, is that employees are using it without guidance from leadership, so it is often happening in secret. Explore this report for further guidance as you consider how AI might fit within your own workplace.

Also of particular interest this week is the survey of 2,778 AI researchers about the state of AI development. Pulled out below is a chart that shows when on aggregate these researchers think AI will meet certain developmental milestones. The horizontal bands in the chart represent the researchers’ estimates for meeting these milestones in 2022 (blue) versus their estimates one year later in 2023 (red). almost all estimates are moving to the left, revealing just how fast the industry is developing.

Last, see the post on OpenAI’s model spec to better understand the specifications OpenAI aims for ChatGPT to follow. This is OpenAI’s first effort to make the behavior of their models more transparent, similar to how Anthropic has committed publicly to their constitutional AI approach.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

Estimates of when AI will reach certain milestones
Estimates of when AI will reach certain milestones

TECH/AI: FEATURED

Microsoft Releases AI Workplace Trends Report

Microsoft · 05/08/24

“Already, AI is being woven into the workplace at an unexpected scale. 75% of knowledge workers use AI at work today, and 46% of users started using it less than six months ago. It’s paying off: Users say AI helps them save time (90%), focus on their most important work (85%), be more creative (84%), and enjoy their work more (83%).”

An Excellent, Excellent Resource On Deepfakes, Including Discussion Questions

AI for Education · 05/10/24

“Since 2019, the presence of Deepfakes - hyperrealistic AI-generated video, photo, and audio forgeries - has surged by 550%, reaching a staggering 95,820 documented deepfake videos in 2023 alone. This blurring of reality requires a new approach to vetting if online content is real or fake. This guide is designed to build student awareness of the presence and impact of deepfakes, while providing key discussion topics on the ethics of AI-generated content.”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

“Is It Fair And Accurate For AI To Grade Standardized Tests?”

EdSurge · 05/03/24

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

Microsoft Bans US Police Departments From Using Its Facial Recognition Tools

TechCrunch · 05/02/24

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

2778 AI Researchers Surveyed On Projections For AI Development

Arxiv · 01/01/24

“The aggregate forecasts give at least a 50% chance of AI systems achieving several milestones by 2028, including autonomously constructing a payment processing site from scratch, creating a song indistinguishable from a new song by a popular musician, and autonomously downloading and fine-tuning a large language model.”

Google Unveils AlphaFold 3

New York Times · 05/08/24

OpenAI Releases Its “Model Spec” - Intended Guidance For How Its Models Should Act

OpenAI · 05/08/24

TECH/AI: USES AND APPLICATIONS

A Short Course On How AlphaFold 2 Uses AI To Predict Protein Structures

European Bioinformatics Institute · 03/01/24

“This tutorial is aimed at researchers who are interested in using AlphaFold2 to predict protein structures and integrate these predictions into their projects. An undergraduate-level knowledge of protein structure and structural biology would be an advantage.”

Kevin Roose Assesses 18 AI Companions

New York Times · 05/09/24

“Part of what I found useful about this experiment was that creating my own A.I. friends forced me to clarify and articulate what I value about my flesh-and-blood friends.”

How To Use AI To Help Plan Your Summer Vacation

New York Times · 05/08/24

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →