The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #467 (November 10, 2024)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Politics, debate, and discussion in the classroom; Character, college, and more

Helpful posts this week —

After a complicated week on school campuses, find a number of posts about managing complex issues and emotions in school communities. More specifically, I’ve been writing for a number of years about the difference between debate (which has a winner and a loser) and discussion (which aims to arrive and shared understanding, if not necessarily agreement). This week’s issue includes a number of articles that span across and stretch beyond this spectrum:

* See Dan Meyer’s feature article on the unavoidably political nature of the classroom. We are practicing politics in our classroom every day in the way we design our learning experiences and engage student voice. See the feature for more.
* Also in the features, see a documentary by PBS on the growth of debate as a pedagogy for building both reasoning skills and civility across difference. Debate surely has an important place in helping students build and shape evidence-based arguments.
* At the same time, see the article in Pedagogy on discussion across difference. How do the strategies in this post further acknowledge the different lived experiences we have, while also providing guidance for how to advance discussion-based discourse during these complicated moments?
Also this week, I was surprised to see an article suggesting that the price of college is going down. While there appears to be a decline of tuition costs in public universities, the article acknowledges that these are because of increased subsidies that counteract rising costs. How reliable these subsidies will be in the future is unknown, and the underlying economics of the rising cost of education appear to be unchanged. This remains an essential topic for every school leader.

For the classroom, find increasingly helpful and nuanced resources on teaching and learning with AI in the AI Update.

Last, someone actually took the time to calculate whether a room full of monkeys would ever actually be able to write a Shakespearean play. I’m grateful the world has enough people in it that someone had the time and desire to look at this question as scientifically as they did, and then publish their findings. A welcome, light bit of science and math that also honors the humanities.

These and more, enjoy.

Peter

FEATURED

Documentary: Can Debate In Classes Drive Engagement and Critical Skills?

PBS · 10/07/24

“In high schools across the country, there is a growing belief that debate-based pedagogies improve civility and academic success by encouraging students to think critically, engage in high-level academic discourse, and construct compelling arguments. We follow students in Boston and Chicago public schools to witness the methodology’s impact.”

The US Is In A National Education Depression. What Will Change It?

Education Daly · 10/28/24

“It was an incredible victory for American schools. Fewer struggling math students meant more opportunities to complete advanced coursework, qualify for good jobs, and earn higher wages. Unbeknownst to us at the time, 2013 turned out to be the high water mark. Achievement stopped improving. First, it stagnated. Then, toward the end of 2010s, it began to decline. And finally, along came COVID."

Politics Is Unavoidable In The Classroom (“You Can’t Opt Out”)

Dan Meyer · 11/06/24

“Politics is the way a society defines which people have value and which people get value. Seen through that lens, teachers are unavoidably practicing politics in their classrooms every day. In classrooms right now, teachers are defining who is valuable, whose ideas are valuable, whose ideas are worth sharing with the rest of the class, who gets which opportunities to learn, who gets to feel like they contributed to their classroom. Given the infinite ideas students bring to their class and the finite time available to teachers, the teacher has to decide, “Will I ask questions that invite or suppress all of those ideas?” That’s a political question. If the teacher allows those ideas to reveal themselves, the teacher then has to decide, “What will I say about all of them? Which ones do I think are valuable? Which ones will I share?” Those are political questions too.”

ARTS

“What Is A Color?”

Juxtapoz · 10/16/24

ASSESSMENT

Why Trojan Horses And Deceptive Assessment Have No Place In Schools

Marc Watkins · 11/03/24

“When you resort to deception to try and catch students cheating, you’ve compromised the values of honesty and transparency that come implicitly attached to our profession… Faculty are decent people. Students are as well. Both are in the wilderness now trying to navigate how to use or resist AI.”

What Is “Authentic Assessment”?

The Mind File · 11/03/24

How One School Shifted from Traditional Grades To Proficiency-Based Grading

EdWeek · 11/05/24

CHARACTER

Tom Brady Had A Bad Scouting Report. They Missed Character.

Billy Oppenheimer · 11/03/24

“When Tom Brady was coming out of college, the scouting report on Brady read, “Poor build. Very skinny and narrow. Lacks mobility. Looks a little frail and lacks great physical stature and strength. Lacks mobility and ability to avoid the rush. Lacks a really strong arm. Can’t drive the ball down the field. Does not throw a really tight spiral.” …Along with his competitiveness and relentless work ethic, Brady’s scouting report could have read: Smart. Great at reading defenses. Stays poised under pressure. Very dedicated to preparation. Lacks an ego. Known for his ability to inspire teammates.”

“Is Convenience Making Our Lives More Difficult?”

Guardian · 11/04/24

“Much of my work with my younger clients has been focused not on deep psychological conflict or the impact of trauma, but on approaching the basic tasks of living, such as making friends, handling work stress, or going to new places. What they tell me repeatedly is that the discomfort of such tasks feels overwhelming, and their worlds are shrinking in consequence.”

CREATIVITY

A Vivid Example Of “Creative Destruction” (At The Bottom)

The Beacon · 10/16/24

CURRICULUM

“Digital Natives” Are A Myth. How To Build Tech Skills

Edutopia · 10/31/24

Should Student Journalists Cover Politics?

EdWeek · 11/01/24

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

Asian American And Pacific Islander Curriculum Grows Around The US

K12 Dive · 11/06/24

“A dozen states had statutes requiring Asian American and Pacific Islander studies curriculum in K-12 schools as of Oct. 3, while recently introduced bills in another four states would require these studies, according to updated research by the nonprofit Committee of 100.”

HEALTH

Should Students Return After Concussions Sooner Rather Than Later?

KFF Health News · 11/05/24

HIGHER ED

Dual HS/College Enrollment Is Skyrocketing, But Is It Leading To College Completion?

Hechinger Report · 10/28/24

“Almost 30 percent of the 400,000 dual enrollees, roughly 117,000 students, earned a bachelor’s degree in four years. But a majority (58 percent) had not earned any college degree, either a four-year bachelor’s or a two-year associate, or any post-secondary credential, such as a short-term certificate, within this four-year period.”

Is The Cost Of College Really Going Down?

The Hill · 10/29/24

“What the future will look like for the cost of higher education is unclear as a big reason for the decrease in prices has been from increases in federal, state and local funding.”

HUMANITIES

“What Can English Teachers Do” In A Time Of “Polycrisis”?

Julian Girdham · 11/08/24

LANGUAGE

Chat, Is This New Teen Slang Real?

Slate · 11/03/24

“Teens are taking slang from the screen to the schoolyard. It’s reshaping the way that they connect with each other and the world.”

“Speaking A Different Language Can Change How You Act And Feel”

Psyche · 10/31/24

LEADERSHIP

What Are “Vital Behaviors” That Help Lead To Desired Outcomes?

SmartBrief · 10/31/24

On Agile Leadership In Education

Tim Dasey · 11/03/24

How Board Discussions Get Sabotaged, And How To Prevent It

MIT Sloan Management Review · 11/06/24

“5 Reasons To Celebrate Small Wins”

SmartBrief · 11/07/24

LEARNING SCIENCE

Culatta: Attack Of The Zombie Learning Theories [Halloween]

LinkedIn · 10/23/24

“You probably know that zombies have a fondness for brains. What you may not know is that zombies also like theories about how the brain works. Zombie Learning Theories, as researcher Bryan Goodwin has explained, are ideas about how we learn that have been killed (i.e., thoroughly debunked by research) yet still roam our classrooms… Let’s meet some of the most common learning zombies so we can recognize them for what they are when they appear.”

PEDAGOGY

On Discussion Across Difference

EdWeek · 08/26/24

Should We Lower Expectations In Times Of Distress?

Higher Ed Praxis · 10/13/24

READING/WRITING

What Is The State Of Reading Among Young People In The UK

National Literacy Trust · 11/01/24

“The number of children and young people who enjoy reading in their free time continues to decline.”

Book Bans Skyrocketed In 2023-24

PEN · 11/01/24

“The 2023-2024 school year recorded the highest instances of book bans and highest number of unique titles banned – over 4,000 unique titles were removed in over 10,000 instances of book bans.”

SAFETY

“4 Key Strategies For School Ransomware Prevention”

K12 Dive · 11/01/24

SOCIAL MEDIA

A Deep Dive Into The Anxious Generation Correlation/Causation Debate

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 11/01/24

STEM

2024 State of Computer Science Education

code.org · 11/01/24

TECH

Grad Student Finds Lost Maya City From His Laptop

Wired · 11/02/24

“So I just started poking around on the internet and eventually got the right combination of search terms and number of Google pages results in and found this data set. As soon as I opened it up I was delighted, surprised, and amazed that the area they had mapped with absolutely no interest in finding archaeological sites at all was really archaeologically important. And one of their survey blocks which was intended to map trees had actually mapped trees growing on top of a really large Maya city that was previously unknown to the scientific community. And it's like a 15-minute walk off the highway.”

“The Consensus Among Scholars Is Clear: Technology And Loneliness Are Interlinked”

New York Times · 11/10/24

“While there was little proof that tech directly made people lonely (plenty of socially connected, healthy people use lots of tech), there was a strong correlation between the two, meaning that those who reported feeling lonely might be using tech in unhealthy ways. The correlation was rooted in three main behaviors:”

Teachers Need Fewer, More Integrated Tech Tools

SmartBrief · 10/29/24

WORKPLACE

Does Starting After Labor Day Disadvantage Students?

74 Million · 11/03/24

GENERAL

“Monkeys Will Never Type Shakespeare, Study Finds”

BBC · 10/31/24

“A Time Of Earnestness”

Kottke · 11/07/24


A.I. Update

AI in instructional design

Last year, I circulated posts suggesting that we were going through a Cambrian explosion of AI technologies and that this year would be the Darwinian natural selection of AI technologies. In other words, this year and the years ahead would be a time of identifying when and how generative AI tools would actually provide value. It appears to be playing out this way. This week’s AI Update is full of increasingly focused use cases and evaluation of use cases.

In the feature section, find Dr. Philippa Hartman’s methodical assessment of how GenAI tools help with planning, and also see an excellent approach to including AI within assignments. Then find additional helpful use cases in the Tech/AI: Education section.

Elsewhere, an article near the end shares how Google recently revealed that a quarter of all code created by Google engineers is generated with AI. Since it is full of early tech adopters, the coding environment is a good advance view of what a future of generative AI supported writing might look like.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

TECH/AI: FEATURED

“Make AI Part Of The Assignment”

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 10/02/24

“I first ask students to “highlight how you used human and machine skills in your learning” in five potential categories, and offer them a range of options to characterize whether and how they used AI tools to do the work… Among the questions I list: What tricky situations arose when you used AI? How did you chart a path through them? Did bouncing ideas off AI spark your creativity? Were there any new exciting directions it led you toward, or did you wind up preferring your own insights independent of using AI? Which of your skills got a real workout from using AI? How do you feel you’ve improved?”

How Good Are GenAI Tools At Instructional Design?

Dr Philippa Hardman · 11/08/24

“Spoiler: my findings underscore that until we have specialised, fine-tuned AI copilots for instructional design, we should be cautious about relying on general-purpose models and ensure expert oversight in all ID tasks.”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

“Considerations For Integrating AI In Math — It’s Complicated”

Carmel Schettino · 11/03/24

“We need to make it so that what students are being asked to learn is not how to factor, but why you might factor a polynomial. Instead of focusing on how to graph trigonometric functions, questions should focus on what affects the graph and why.”

“The Near Future Of GenAI In Education: Part Two”

Leon Furze · 11/05/24

“Offline AI… Wearables… Agents”

“What We’re Trying With AI, Part 2”

Global Online Academy · 05/28/24

“What Happens When An AI Assistant Helps The Tutor, Instead Of The Student”

EdWeek · 10/31/24

Easy Prompts For Building Your Own AI Teaching Assistant

Harvard Business Publishing · 10/31/24

A Well Organized AI Literacy Framework, Loosely Bloom-Like

University of Adelaide · 11/01/24

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

“Can AI Influence How You Feel About Someone… Without You Knowing?”

Future of Being Human · 11/03/24

“Imagine that you’re talking with someone over Zoom and, as the conversation goes on, you begin to feel that they really get you — to the extent that a strong bond of trust quickly forms. Now imagine that this sense of trust is the result of an AI that, unknown to either of you, is manipulating facial features in real time to influence how each of you feels about the other.”

HR AI Overwhelmingly Prefer White And Male Candidates

Geekwire · 10/31/24

A Free Course On Deepfakes In Education, Made With Deepfakes

Leon Furze · 11/01/24

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

“Introducing ChatGPT Search”

OpenAI · 10/31/24

The Story Of How Deep Learning AI Caught Everyone By Surprise

Understanding AI · 11/05/24

TECH/AI: USES AND APPLICATIONS

More Than A Quarter Of New Code At Google Is Generated By AI

Ars Technica · 10/30/24

Less Skilled Workers Benefit More From AI In The Workplace

MIT Sloan Management Review · 11/04/24

Meta Permits Its Models To Be Used By The US Military

New York Times · 11/04/24

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →