The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #464 (October 16, 2024)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Lighthouse parents, assessment practices, 1:1s, and more

An excellent week (and a bit),

In this week’s features, find a reprint of the Atlantic piece on “lighthouse parents” (as different from “helicopter parents” and “snowplow parents”). Also, see a helpful collection of pedagogical moves for engaging students during lectures. It’s a helpful reminder that there are many excellent ways to teach a class, and not one pedagogy to rule them all.

Also find a deep dive on Bloom’s two sigma problem, on time for innovation, on the 2024 educator confidence report, and more.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

“6 Research-Backed Ways To Break Up Your Lectures”

Edutopia · 09/27/24

“In a 2024 study, researchers compared a long lecture block followed by active learning activities—small group work and pop quizzes, for example—with an approach that interspersed the two approaches. They found that students learned the most when short lectures were punctuated by three-minute active learning activities… Here are six research-based activities—typically taking no longer than a few minutes—to break up your lectures and promote better learning.”

“Lighthouse Parents Have More Confident Kids”

Larry Cuban · 10/08/24

“A parent’s first instinct is often to remove obstacles from their child’s path, obstacles that feel overwhelming to them but are easily navigable by us. This urge has led to pop-culture mythology around pushy parenting styles, including the “Helicopter Parent,” who flies in to rescue a child in crisis, and the “Snowplow Parent,” who flattens any obstacle in their child’s way… I want to make a case for the Lighthouse Parent, a term that the pediatrician Kenneth Ginsburg and others have used. A Lighthouse Parent stands as a steady, reliable guide, providing safety and clarity without controlling every aspect of their child’s journey.”

ARTS

How The Impressionists Revolutionized The World Of Painting

New York Times · 10/10/24

“Gérôme’s edges are crisp, where Monet’s are all hazy. His brushwork is invisible, where Monet’s is active and advertised. This was what artistic talent was supposed to be in 1874. Drama. Polish. Technique. Not some little sketch of a sunrise over a fisherman’s wharf.”

ASSESSMENT

“What Music Has Taught Me About Grading”

Robert Talbert · 10/07/24

“I have a reputation among my bandmates for taking notes. I bring a little notepad and a pen with me to gigs and rehearsals as part of my gear and keep them next to me. If we're playing in a bar, in between sets while everyone else is getting a beer, I'm frantically scribbling notes from the previous set… Why do I do this? Why do I evaluate so carefully and give feedback so mercilessly? It's easy: I want the music to be as good as possible.”

Should Schools Have Minimum Grades?

ASCD · 10/01/24

“Grades And Standardized Test Scores Aren’t Matching Up”

EdWeek · 10/04/24

Interview With College Board’s Head Of AP About AP Test Grading

EdWeek · 10/08/24

CHARACTER

On Grit And How To Set Goals

Billy Oppenheimer · 10/13/24

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

Students Feel Less Connected To Each Other At School

EdWeek · 10/08/24

CDC Survey: “3% Of American High Schoolers Identify As Transgender”

New York Times · 10/08/24

White College Enrollment Is Declining, Hispanic Enrollment Climbing

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 10/10/24

HISTORY OF EDUCATION

How Vocational Education Became Career And Technical Education

Larry Cuban · 10/05/24

LEADERSHIP

Some Ideas For Topics During 1:1 Meetings With Reports

Leadership Freak · 10/07/24

LEARNING SCIENCE

Melinda French Gates: Not Getting Enough Sleep Is “So Dumb”

Inc. · 10/07/24

PEDAGOGY

“On Bloom’s Two Sigma Program: A Systematic Review”

Nintil · 07/28/19

SAFETY

“How to Fortify Your School Networks After a Cyberattack”

EdTEch Magazine · 10/04/24

SOCIAL MEDIA

Who Do US Adults Follow On TikTok?

Pew Research · 10/08/24

STEM

Stephen Wolfram: “On The Nature Of Time”

Stephen Wolfram · 10/08/24

Researchers Develop New 3D Printing Technique

MIT · 10/10/24

WORKPLACE

“Private School Choice: What The Research Says”

EdWeek · 10/10/24

“This school year, for the first time ever, more than 1 million of the nation’s 50 million K-12 children took advantage of private school choice, according to the nonprofit EdChoice, a leading advocate. A closer look at the private school choice literature reveals some consistent findings as well as a number of gaps in understanding. That’s in part because measuring the effects of private school choice on outcomes like student-test scores is no easy task.”

2024 Educator Confidence Report Is Out

HMH · 10/01/24

“How To Give Busy People The Time To Innovate”

Harvard Business Review · 10/08/24

GENERAL

Comedy Wildlife Photography: 2024 Finalists

Comedy Wildlife · 10/04/24

A Big Picture Look At Education In America As The Election Nears

New York Times · 10/09/24

“Piece By Piece” - A Lego Documentary of Pharrell Williams

New York Times · 10/11/24

“Quantifying The ‘Kevin Bacon Game’: A Statistical Approach”

Digg · 10/12/24


A.I. Update

AI tutoring and tutoring support are showing positive results

Some excellent posts this week.

Most significantly, research is beginning to bear out the ways in which generative AI tools can support learning, and especially tutoring. As is increasingly understood, these cases are not about replacing people, but about supporting people. See several posts this week — both in the features and education section — on this topic.

Also, for those interested in the quest for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), find several posts on the challenge of simply trying to define what AGI is.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

TECH/AI: FEATURED

Stanford Research: AI-Assisted Tutoring Yield Positive Results

The 74 Million · 10/07/24

“The new study offers a middle ground in what’s become a polarized debate between supporters and detractors of AI tutoring. It’s also the first randomized controlled trial — the gold standard in research — to examine a human-AI system in live tutoring. In all, about 1,000 students got help from about 900 tutors, and students who worked with AI-assisted tutors were four percentage points more likely to master the topic after a given session than those in a control group whose tutors didn’t work with AI. Students working with lower-rated tutors saw their performance jump more than twice as much, by nine percentage points. In all, their pass rate went from 56% to 65%, nearly matching the 66% pass rate for students with higher-rated tutors.”

Survey: ”AI In The Workplace” - A Helpful Overview

Gallup · 10/08/24

“White-collar workers are more likely to be using AI. White-collar workers are, by far, the most frequent users of AI in their roles. While 81% of employees in production/frontline industries say they never use AI, only 54% of white-collar workers say they never do and 15% report using AI weekly.”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

“The Future of College Is Hybrid” — With AI

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 10/03/24

“This shift toward collaborating with AI doesn’t unsettle Myers or Murdaugh in the way that it has many professors. The reason, they say, is that the skills that students use to engage thoughtfully with AI are the same ones that colleges are good at teaching. Namely: knowing how to obtain and use information, thinking critically and analytically, and understanding what and how you’re trying to communicate.”

“Tutor Copilot: A Human-AI Approach For Scaling Real Time Expertise”

National Student Support Accelerator · 10/07/24

“Following a preregistered analysis plan, we find that students working on mathematics with tutors randomly assigned to have access to Tutor CoPilot are 4 percentage points (p.p.) more likely to master topics (p<0.01). Notably, students of lower-rated tutors experienced the greatest benefit, improving mastery by 9 p.p. relative to the control group.”

Some Teachers Use AI To Help Write Recommendation Letters

EdWeek · 10/08/24

“About half of the 130 teachers who said they used AI to help with their recommendation letters did so to take the stress out of the task, according to foundry10’s survey. And about a third of the 130 said they believed AI tools improved the quality of their letters. Far more teachers, 267 in all, said they did not use AI tools to help craft their letters of recommendation. About half said they steered clear of AI because they worried that their letters would lack a personal touch. And a little over 40 percent worried about the ethics of passing off work written at least partially by AI as their own.”

On The “Buttonification” Of Instructional Design With AI

Dr Philippa Hardman · 10/11/24

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

Maybe AI’s Energy Needs Will Be Good For The Planet

Ben James · 10/02/24

“If you asked me how to scale clean energy, I would prescribe a magical source of urgent energy demand. Someone willing to pay a premium to build solar+batteries, geothermal, and nuclear, in order to bring them down the cost curve and make them cheaper for everyone. That is exactly what AI data centres are. For the first time ever, securing clean 24/7 power is an urgent strategic priority for the most powerful organisations in the world.”

Governments Are Starting To Coordinate On AI Safety

Brookings · 10/04/24

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

“The Frustrating Quest To Define AGI”

Center for Curriculum Redesign · 10/01/24

“The AI community has been loose in its use of anthropocentric language, using words such as “emergence” rather than “thresholding,” “reasoning” rather than “reckoning” and “retrieval,” “understanding” rather than “pattern-matching,” and “hallucination” rather than “confabulation.” Mercifully, after a couple of years of thrashing around with definitions and counter-definitions of Intelligence, a stasis has been reached where both psychologists and AI experts seem to agree that this is a dead-end, since the concept of Intelligence is too fluid to be pinned down. But if “Intelligence” cannot be defined properly, how can “Generalized Intelligence” fare any better?”

Wait, What Even Is AGI? Even Fei-Fei Li Isn’t Sure

TechCrunch · 10/03/24

Hear An AI Podcast On The Arrival Of AI Podcasts (It’s Pretty Good!)

AI and Education · 10/07/24

“State of AI Report 2024”

State of AI · 10/10/24

LLMs Don’t Reason — Apple Says This Is A Problem

Gary Marcus · 10/11/24

TECH/AI: USES AND APPLICATIONS

“An AI Model Helped Uncover 303 Previously Unseen Nazca Lines In Peru”

Colossal · 09/26/24

What A Small Group Of Students Think About Social AI

LinkedIn · 10/08/24

"AI Won’t Make Art, But It Will Help Us Get Work Done”

LinkedIn · 10/09/24

Nobel Prize In Chemistry Goes To AI Software Founders

Nobel Prize · 10/09/24

TECH/AI: OTHER

Nicholas Carr: Are LLMs “Dead Speech”?

New Cartographies · 10/10/24

“If, as Marx argued, capital is dead labor, then the products of large language models might best be understood as dead speech. Just as factory workers produce, with their “living labor,” machines and other forms of physical capital that are then used, as “dead labor,” to produce more physical commodities, so human expressions of thought and creativity—“living speech” in the forms of writing, art, photography, and music—become raw materials used to produce “dead speech” in those same forms.”

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →