The Educator's Notebook

A weekly collection of education-related news from around the web.

Educator’s Notebook #465 (October 21, 2024)

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →

Invention and creativity, finding common ground, and more

An excellent week.

It was about 13 years ago that the topic of creativity was buzzing with new books and essays, and now people are talking and writing about it again, perhaps because of AI. In this week’s features, find one article on the mechanics of teaching the creative habit within our disciplines and a second one how AI may be fundamentally changing the way scientific discovery is happening. Later in the Creativity section, add in a video essay with a technique for generating ideas.

Elsewhere this week, find articles about ways in which we can find our way out of the culture wars: on finding common ground amidst a DEI backlash, on how we can talk about elections in charged times, and even on Shakespeare in times of literary diversification.

Plus a robust AI section below to boot.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

FEATURED

A Fundamental Shift Is Happening In How Science Happens

New York Times · 10/13/24

“These were outstanding and fundamentally human accomplishments, to be sure. But the Nobel recognition underscored a chilling prospect: Henceforth, perhaps scientists will merely craft the tools that make the breakthroughs, rather than do the revolutionary work themselves or even understand how it came about. Artificial intelligence designs and builds hundreds of molecular Notre Dames and Hagia Sophias, and a researcher gets a pat for inventing the shovel.”

How To Teach Creativity: An Excellent Systems And Skills Approach

Teacher Magazine · 10/16/24

“Although historically associated with a more inquiry-based approach, this article focuses on the development of creativity as part of a knowledge-rich curriculum. It describes the role of subject-specific knowledge in the development of creative expertise and highlights effective strategies for nurturing creativity with specific examples from English, Science and Technology, and Creative Arts.”

ATHENA

So Startups Have A Chance Vs Big Tech?

Cowboy · 09/21/24

CHARACTER

Factors That Lead To And Reduce Loneliness

Gallup · 10/15/24

CREATIVITY

A Technique For Generating Ideas

Everything is a Remix · 10/15/24

DIVERSITY/INCLUSION

“Female Mountain Bikers Backflip Their Way To Equality”

New York Times · 10/16/24

What Went Wrong With U Michigan’s DEI Work?

New York Times · 10/16/24

Jal Mehta On Finding Common Ground In DEI Discussions

American Enterprise Institute · 10/17/24

HIGHER ED

Interpreting the Financial ROI On Liberal Arts Colleges

American Enterprise Institute · 10/10/24

HUMANITIES

“Two-Thirds Of Gaza’s Buildings Have been Damaged Or Destroyed”

Reuters · 10/05/24

“That’s almost three times as many buildings as there are in Manhattan island, New York.”

Tips For Teaching Elections In Politically Charged Times

Harvard Graduate School of Education · 09/25/24

“10 Most Common Questions Teenagers Asked About The Election”

Chalkbeat · 10/10/24

“Children’s Books About Elections That Might Inspire Grown-Ups, Too”

New York Times · 10/10/24

Untouched Tomb Discovered Under Petra

New York Times · 10/14/24

“Five Essential Books For Understanding Native American History”

Literary Hub · 10/17/24

What Is The Fate Of William Shakespeare In Theaters Today?

New York Times · 10/21/24

LEADERSHIP

Cynefin Framework: How To Make Decisions In Unprecedented Times

IT Revolution · 07/05/21

LEARNING SCIENCE

How Retrieval Practice Can Reduce Test Anxiety

JARMC · 07/12/14

PD

“What If You Can’t Remove Bias From Course Evaluations?”

Chronicle of Higher Ed · 10/16/24

PEDAGOGY

“5 Conditions For Getting Formative Assessment Right”

Cult of Pedagogy · 10/14/24

READING/WRITING

Students Do Read Full Books In School

Carrie Santo-Thomas · 10/04/24

Are Leveled Books Good For Developing Readers?

EdWeek · 10/14/24

SOCIAL MEDIA

Surgeon General: How To Responsibly Manage Social Media For Kids

EdWeek · 10/17/24

STEM

On The Use Of Visuals (Instead Of Tricks) When Teaching Fractions

EdWeek · 10/07/24

Play The Binary Game: Quickly Translating Decimal To Binary

Cisco Learning Network · 10/21/24

TECH

PICRAT: An Alternative To SAMR For Evaluating Education Technology

CITE Journal · 10/01/20

WORKPLACE

On “Place Authenticity” As A Force In Personal Development

Psyche · 10/10/24

On The Need To Build Career Advancement For Teachers

EdSurge · 10/16/24

Teacher Turnover Increased After Implementing Four Day Weeks

EdWeek · 10/17/24

GENERAL

“Every Single Person Who Confuses Correlation and Causation Ends Up Dying” [Cartoon]

Instagram · 10/04/24

On The End Of A Beloved Sugar Maple Tree

New York Times · 10/16/24


A.I. Update

How we talk about tech, what risks are growing, how AI is powered, and more

So much of our discourse around AI reflects a binary “with us or against us” mindset. Many people are “for” AI, and many others are “against” it. This is a mistake, of course, as is binary thinking in most complex conversations. In this week’s AI section, find several posts that aim to help us move away from this kind of binary thinking.

In the features, Maha Bali’s chapter on cake-making as an analogy for how we use AI in the classroom brilliantly offers a spectrum of approaches, from “making from scratch” to buying a cake complete from the bakery. When might we bake from scratch, and why? When might we pick up a cake from the store and why? And the natural analogy: when might learn completely by hand? And when might we learn aided by artificial intelligence? Bali dives more deeply into the kinds of questions the analogy poses for how we practice our learning in schools.

Also in the features, find an edge case that highlights risks of vague AI practices and policies. The conditions for this court case are extreme, but worth considering how outcomes are experienced on a smaller scale in most school cases.

Also this week, find Miriam Reynoldson’s helpful practice of “affirmative critique” as an aid to talking with colleagues about AI, find harrowing evidence of the risks of AI, find a detailed description by Sequoia Capital of agentic reasoning, which promises to be the next phase of AI development, and much more, including one doctor’s reflection on how generative AI does better at the human work of bedside conversations with patients than he does.

Our world is undergoing such extraordinary change right now.

These and more, enjoy!

Peter

TECH/AI: FEATURED

“Parents Sue School… After Son Punished For Using AI On Paper”

ABC News · 10/15/24

“The filing accuses the school of a lack of clarity in its rules about AI use, saying the school handbook did not "have any established rules, policies or procedures for not only the use of artificial intelligence, but what any administrators, faculty or students should do when encountering its use.”"

Cake-Making As An Analogy For Setting Generative AI Guidelines

UEN · 10/21/24

“One way is making a cake from scratch, buying all the ingredients and making it yourself. Another way is to get a readymade cake mix (like Betty Crocker) and build the cake. Another way is to buy a good quality cake readymade from a bakery. The last way is to get it from the supermarket, a low-quality version like a Twinkie… What is the difference in quality between what you can bake from scratch and buy from a bakery? When might you do one and not the other?”

TECH/AI: EDUCATION

What Happened In OpenAI’s Ed Forum At EdTech Week?

Marc Watkins · 10/14/24

“All The Literacies Besides AI Literacy” For Responsible AI Use

Maha Bali · 10/15/24

The First-Mile, Last-Mile Problem With EdTech

Dan Meyer · 10/16/24

“Affirmative Critique” — An Approach To Your Contentious AI Conversations

The Mind File · 10/18/24

TECH/AI: ETHICS AND RISK

What Happens When Non-Consensual Explicit Deepfakes Proliferate

AP News · 10/03/24

“Three years after the 30-year-old South Korean woman received a barrage of online fake images that depicted her nude, she is still being treated for trauma. She struggles to talk with men. Using a mobile phone brings back the nightmare. “It completely trampled me, even though it wasn’t a direct physical attack on my body,” she said in a phone interview with The Associated Press. She didn’t want her name revealed because of privacy concerns.”

Should Autonomous Weapons Make Life Or Death Decisions?

TechCrunch · 10/11/24

“For many in Silicon Valley and Washington, D.C., the biggest fear is that China or Russia rolls out fully autonomous weapons first, forcing the U.S.’s hand. At a UN debate on AI arms last year, a Russian diplomat was notably coy. “We understand that for many delegations the priority is human control,” he said. “For the Russian Federation, the priorities are somewhat different.””

Yuval Noah Harari Interview On The Risks Of AI

Noema · 10/09/24

TECH/AI: INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT

OpenAI Releases “Canvas” As A Response To Claude “Artifacts”

TechCrunch · 10/03/24

“Meta Announces Movie Gen, An AI Powered Video Generator”

The Verge · 10/04/24

“The Agentic Reasoning Era Begins”

Sequoia Capital · 10/09/24

“Hungry For Energy, Amazon, Google And Microsoft Turn To Nuclear”

New York Times · 10/16/24

TECH/AI: USES AND APPLICATIONS

“I’m A Doctor. ChatGPT’s Bedside Manner Is Better Than Mine.”

New York Times · 10/05/24

This Company Is Trying To Automate Invention

IEEE · 10/08/24

TECH/AI: OTHER

Dario Amodei Offers Optimistic Vision Of A Future With AI

Dario Amodei · 10/01/24

“Wikipedia Declares War On AI Slop”

Futurism · 10/10/24

Six High Level Questions About AI For Leaders

McKinsey · 10/16/24

← Previous Issue · Next Issue →